Ringing In the New Year with Columbia Classics... Volume 2

Welcome to 2022, guys!  I've got so much stuff I want to cover this year, including finishing up on this massive 14-disc UHD/ BD boxed set, Columbia Classics Volume 2.  First post of the new year is appropriate for this one, though, as it may well take the prize for Best Release of 2021.  Anyway, I've now covered four of the main features on their individual movie pages:
...which leaves two more: 1959's Anatomy Of a Murder and 1968's Oliver!  See, it's one film for each decade from the '50s to the 2010s.  Well, almost.  But the gap is happily filled with a bonus disc of 20 short films, ranging from the early 1930s to the late 2010s.

Update 4/23/2026: Welcome to 2026, guys!  It's Update Megaweek, and I've added Sony's 2005 Oliver! DVD to the mix.  I could've included this disc in 2022, but as the film from the set I was least interested, I let myself be lazy.  But today's the today I kick myself in the butt, get in gear, and give you some historical context to Sony's fancy 4k set.
Here's my review of Otto Preminger's Anatomy Of a Murder in eight words: important film, still engaging but hasn't aged well.  When people like Paul Schrader talk about The Searchers, they tend not to mention the "aw shucks" homestead scenes, the goofy comic relief, sappy romance or the cornball musical number.  But it's all there, right alongside everything great about the film.  And it's kind of the same here, except where in The Searchers it feels almost like two different movies cutting back and forth to each other, here it feels more inseparably stirred into a single stew.  You've got some of the most authentic court room scenes on film for its time, an envelope pushing jazz score by the one and only Duke Ellington (which sometimes works great, and sometimes sounds like it's intended for a completely different movie), and a solid story at its core, based on the John D. Voelker novel, which in turn was based on an actual 1952 murder trial.  But for all its touted authenticity, they certainly took some big, Hollywood liberties, including adding a very old Hollywood femme fatale plot twister.  You can read about the real story here; it's much more down to Earth.
Ain't no rule that says the dog can't practice law!
But that old Hollywood sensibility really feels out of place when we meet Arthur O'Connell as the comically drunken stumble-bum sidekick.  It's so hokey.  George C. Scott probably comes off the best, though non-actor Joseph N. Welch, who in real life was the chief counsel in the historical Army-McCarthy hearings, is memorably affable as the judge.  Jimmy Stewart is Jimmy Stewart, Ben Gazzara gives more of a presence than a performance and Lee Remick, well, feels like she's still performing in Days of Wine and Roses rather than a true crime story.  At the end of the day, Anatomy's still eminently watchable, but I don't think it packs nearly the same punch it would've in the 50s.
Anatomy's been released multiple times before, first in 2000 as a fullscreen Columbia Classics DVD, which was later included in their 2007 Best Of 50's Collection and 2008 James Stewart: Columbia Screen Legends 3-disc boxed sets.  It was the same disc in all those cases.  In 2012, Criterion released it on DVD and Blu in 2012 with a new widescreen transfer.  And in 2013, Sony released that version as a widescreen MOD DVDR in their Choice Collection line.  And of course, most recently, it's here in this set, on both BD and UHD.
1) 2000 DVD; 2) 2012 DVD; 3) 2013 DVDR; 4) 2021 BD; 5) 2021 UHD.

The original 2000 DVD is somewhat open matte at 1.32:1, with more on the top and bottom, but cropping off a little on the sides.  All the rest are 1.85:1... well, except for the 2013 Choice Collection disc, which is ever so slightly horizontally stretched to 1.84:1.  But basically, they all seem to be based on the same scan, which was restored in 4k from the original 35mm negative and the duplicate 35mm negative.  So yes, it's the same master on all of these, even the newest release.  But it looks great in HD - grain is very finely captured even on the BD - and new grading was of course performed for the UHD's HDR.

Even the old 2000 disc includes not only the original English mono track with optional subtitles (both standard and HoH), but a Spanish dub and Chinese, Korean, Portuguese, Spanish and Thai subs.  Criterion stripped away all the foreign options but kept the English mono and subtitles, and adding a new 5.1upmix to boot.  The Choice Collection took it all away apart from the original mono, but what do you expect from a DVDR?  But the boxed set really went all out, giving us the original mono, newly restored for this release, and that 5.1 track, both in DTS-HD on the BD and UHD, with an all new Atmos mix on the latter to boot.  It's also got multiple foreign dubs and well over 20 foreign subs, with both standard and HoH English subtitle tracks.  In other words: all you could ask for and more.
The initial DVD of this film was barebones apart from the trailer, but Criterion cooked up a nice collection of new and vintage features.  They conducted a series of on-camera interviews with experts, each of which is rather smart and devoted to a particular topic (i.e. one on Saul Bass, another on Duke Ellington).  As to the vintage, they have an old television interview with Preminger and a newsreel about the film with some behind-the-scenes footage.  But best of all are the "excerpts" from the Anatomy of Anatomy documentary, which visits the town where the film was shot and interviews the locals who witnessed or even participated in the filming.  I put excerpts in quotes because the feature on the disc is over 30 minutes long, and the complete doc itself is less than 45, so we're really getting the bulk of the documentary.  There's also a photo gallery and a 28-page booklet with notes by Nick Pinkerton.

The Columbia set keeps many of the Criterion extras, but sadly loses Anatomy of Anatomy, the newsreel and the gallery.  Sony does come up with something in their stead though, an audio commentary by one of the experts interviewed on the Criterion (which, again, has been ported over).  It's quite good and informative, and  a refreshing alternative to the current trend of self-indulgent expert tracks on many cult films these days.  But serious fans would still do well to hang onto their Criterion discs for those excised supplements.
Watching the lavish musical Oliver! for the first time, I was surprised to realize it's the source of "Food, Glorious Food," that song from all the silly commercials in the 80s.  It's also the home of "Consider Yourself," that song theater kids have been singing to themselves for decades.  The first - and unfortunately, last - thing that struck me, however, were the immense production values, where even the city exteriors are constructed sets, including London streets with a working training running through it.  And when the time comes, they're able to fill it all with massive crowds of singers and dancers.  You can't help but be impressed.  It also sports an expert cast, including Ron Moody from the original stage show and the inimitable Oliver Reed.

But while all the songs are first rate, musically, lyrically, they often feel like the first words that popped into the writer's head.  Like, the one verse in "I'd Do Anything," when Faigin sings to his kids is on point, but everything else is simple and unimaginative like "would you lace my shoe?  Would you paint your face blue?"  Mrs. Johnson's Fourth Grade Class could've come up with more amusing suggestions.  A little touch of Porter or Berlin would've gone a long way.  As soon as Twist sings "I could see it at my leisure," in the "Who Will Buy" song, you just know the rhyme is going to be "treasure," and sure enough, there are no surprises.  And even when Faigan sings his perfectly crafted "Reviewing the Situation" song, you just can't escape that this is a children's movie, and it doesn't hold enough dramatic weight for adult viewers.  And this is Dickens.  Very heavy issues here are turned into light forth, and having a grown woman lip sync the title character has an unfortunate distancing effect for viewers old enough to take a critical view.
Oliver! was first released on DVD by Sony in 1998, and again in 2005, this time packaged with a soundtrack CD.  I've got that one for us today.  Then, in 2008, they included it in their mammoth Columbia Pictures: The Best Pictures box.  Twilight Time gave the musical its HD debut on blu in 2013, limited as always to 3000 copies, and Sony later released their own BD edition in 2018.  I haven't got any of those editions, because frankly, I wouldn't even own this one if it wasn't part of the set.  But it is, so I do, and it's a new 2-disc BD/ UHD set giving us the film in true 4k for the first time with all new special features.
1) 2005 DVD; 2) 2021 BD; 3) 2021 UHD.
The DVD is anamorphic widescreen, but also slightly windowboxed to 2.34:1.  The screenshots speak for itself in terms of how much compression noise it has, and the colors are red and flat compared to the new discs.  Now, the book tells us this restoration was done in 2020-21, so it's not the same master used on any of the previous blu-rays.  It's been freshly scanned in 4k from the OCN, apart from two missing reels that had to be taken from a 35mm interpositive.  The framing's been slightly adjusted to 2.35:1 and looks stellar.  The BD might actually be a pinch too bright here, with some of the whitest highlights losing tiny bits of detail that the UHD recovers.  The increased resolution also restores natural curves and rounded edges to small detail that is blocky and pixelated on the BD.  So it's a very fine BD, but the UHD is an improvement on top of that in every natural way that you'd expect.

The DVD started us off with a 5.1 mix (the original '98 DVD did, too), plus a French stereo track and English & French subs.  The BD and UHD share the same, lossless choices of stereo and 5.1 mixes, as well as nine foreign language dubs, some of which are lossless on the UHD (but are all lossy on the blu).  The pair also include both English and English HoH subtitles, as well as a slew of foreign subs.
Oliver all grown up.
Oliver! just came with the original 1968 featurette and the trailer on DVD (well, plus that soundtrack CD).  But this newer version raises the bar.  It has a hefty collection of sing-alongs, dance-alongs and sing- & dance-alongs that's mostly just repeated footage of the film with lyrics and dance steps on the screen.  But there's also a healthy dose of quality content, including another excellent expert commentary track.  There are great on-camera interviews with stars Mark Lester and Ron Moody, a brief featurette comparing the elaborate sets with the original locations they're modeled after, that vintage featurette from the DVD, original screen test footage of Jack Wild (The Artful Dodger) and several trailers.  Even if you're not interested in the musical itself, you might well find the story behind such a massive undertaking intriguing.
Finally, we come to the bonus disc, itself a collection of twenty beautifully restores short films, mostly ranging from 1933-1956, with three more from 2002, 2016 and 2017.  There's a Three Stooges short, two Charley Chases and a 1950's travelogue with a big music number.  The animated entries include a lot of childrens' stuff, naturally, including several I remember being shown in grade school.  There's an adaptation of the children's book Madeline that mirrors its distinctive illustrations, a dark and eclectic illustration of Edgar Allen Poe's Tell-Tale Heart, an early Tom & Jerry/ Sylvester & Tweety-style backyard adventure, a couple Mr. Magoos, and even modern CGI features that've popularly played before Columbia blockbusters, including a Hotel Transylvania short.  But the jewel in the crown is 1933's Um-Pa, an utterly insane musical short starring vaudeville star Jack Osterman that's been touted on the internet for years, and exceeds the hype with every unpredictable new twist.  It's one you've really got to see for yourself.  And now, for the first time ever, it can be seen in the level of quality it deserves.
What? You didn't think Jar Jar Binks would be in at least one of these films?
So this is a pretty damn essential set.  Six irrefutably classic films, all making their debut on UHD, many with all new special features to boot.  Stripes also includes never before-seen deleted scenes and The Social Network is being released for the first time ever with its original, unrated audio.  And the bonus disc is a treasure trove, even if not all of them are apt to be to your interests.  It's all housed in a very sturdy box with an impressively sized, full-color, 80 page hardcover book with essays on all six films and write-ups on each of their restorations.  It's 14 discs in total, with each film given its own case and slipcover and a sleeve in the back of the book for the bonus disc.  A download card is also included.  So yeah, if you ask me what was the best home video release of 2021, this was probably it.

Red's 25th, 27th and 40th Anniversary Editions

Warren Beatty's Reds is one of those rare films that really lives up to its legacy. It really deserves all of its Academy Awards. Everything was just done so right, and beyond what you'd expect, from the writing to the fantastic cast. When you see movies like Dick Tracy or Bulworth, you wonder what happened to that early Warren Beatty who made such a masterpiece? But Reds is also a bitch to get on blu-ray. Paramount made an excellent 25th Anniversary edition, and a separate DVD release, including a terrific little documentary on the film, when blu-rays were just coming out back in 2006, and most people hadn't yet adopted. In fact, there was an HD-DVD for this, too, because we were just in the beginning of the format wars at the time. They did reissue it in 2008 (which is why most online release dates show the 25th Anniversary disc coming out on the film's 27th anniversary), but even that's long out of print. The cheapest unused copy on Amazon is $74 as of this writing, and it was higher last time I looked, so you might want to jump on it. Or try to find an import that doesn't cost even more once you factor in the shipping.

Update 5/5/15 - 12/27/21: Six and a half years later, and Reds is finally back in print.  What's more, it's a new 4k restoration as part of the Paramount Presents line.  Woot!
Reds is the true story of journalist/poet/political activist John Reed, who wound up playing a huge role in the Bolshevik Revolution. It starts out with, and continually returns to, documentary interviews with real people from Jack's life, recounting their memories of him, but the bulk of the film is played out by a fantastic cast including Beatty, of course, along with Diane Keaton, Jack Nicholson (as Eugene O'Neill), Maureen Stapleton, Paul Sorvino and Gene Hackman. The tagline for the film was, "Not since Gone With The Wind has there been a great romantic epic like it," and I daresay this film fully lives up to that hyperbolic claim. And perhaps unlike Gone With the Wind, Reds is just as powerful and moving today as it was the year of its release. Everything from the complex politics to the tragic romance flourish in this lavish production, with a very memorable score by Stephen Sondheim and a directorial style that actually feels reminiscent of classic Woody Allen, but on a grander scale.

So it sucked that you couldn't find a copy for a reasonable price for so long. I've still got copies of both US blu-ray editions here, as well as the original DVD release (surprisingly, the 25th Anniversary was also the film's DVD debut). But hopefully we can forget about all that and just pick up the new 40th Anniversary edition.  All it needs to be is affordable - check! - and definitive...  Check?
1) 2006 DVD; 2) 2006 BD; 3) 2008 BD; 4) 2021 BD.

The short scoop on the 2006 and 2008 blu-rays is, apart from the tackier artwork, the two editions are identical. Same transfer, same menus, everything. They did stick different labels on the discs themselves, but that's it. A small thing to note is that, regardless of which edition you're looking at, apart from the 40th, they did leave little bits of black and odds and ends in the overscan area, leaving the AR at about 1.77:1 throughout. It's really, really on the fringe, varies from shot to shot, and most viewers probably won't see it because they haven't reset their scan for proper 100% 16x9 anyway; but it is there. I guess in 2006, they figured no one would ever see outside the TV safe zone. The new blu, however, is properly matted to 1.85:1, while still revealing more image around the edges than ever before.  The framing has definitely been improved.
See those black edges? That's the overscan stuff I was talking about.
Apart from that, it's always been a pretty nice transfer, especially for such early blus. And seeing as they were concurrent releases, it only makes sense that the DVD has the same transfer as the first two BDs, in terms of framing, colors, etc. But of course, one is in HD and the other SD, so the DVD is naturally softer, more compressed and doesn't hold up as well on large monitors, as we can see when we get in close. The lines of Sorvino's features get pretty mushy on the DVD, above, which even the old blu-ray fixes up rather nicely.  But the new blu is an improvement in this regard, too.  Even though this isn't in HDR (being a standard BD and not a UHD), we can still see the benefits of the greater color range in the scans.  Look at the reflections in Sorvino's glasses, for instance, which are blocky and blown out on the old blu and more naturally faded on the new.  The grain is also softer than it would be on UHD, but it's much more filmic and better encoded this latest time around.  The color timing's different, too, something that really stands out comparing the now warmer interview segments.  I guess you could say they raised the reds.  Nyuk, nyuk
It's a nice little upgrade in the audio department, too, though still a bit disappointing.  The DVD and blu both gave us the option between the original mono and a modestly rejiggered 5.1 (plus a French dub on the DVD and French and Spanish on the BD).  Unfortunately, the old BD audio was as lossy as the DVD.  And this new version?  Well, the 5.1 is now lossless DTS-HD, but unfortunately the mono is still lossy.  Oh well.  At least it's a step in the right direction.

All three discs also offer optional English subtitles, with the 25/27th BDs also offering French and Spanish, and the 40th giving us both standard and HoH English subs.
Extras-wise, all editions are the same.  They're all mixed together into one, feature-length (about 75 minutes) documentary, which is a very satisfying, all-you-need-to-know look back at the film, primarily based on a very substantive interview with Beatty himself.  But it also involves interviews with Nicholson, Sorvino, Paramount execs... basically everybody except Keaton.  It's great.  There's also a "DVD trailer" (yes, even on the 40th edition), which is a newly made trailer that's actually pretty corny.  It's a small thing, but one can't help wondering what happened to the original theatrical trailer?
I originally ended this post asking Paramount for an updated 35th Anniversary edition next year. Beatty was making his big comeback film, his first film since 1998, so I said the two projects could surely drum up some glowing publicity and sales for each other. Well, maybe Paramount did the right thing by waiting. But ultimately they've done the right thing, putting this masterpiece back into print, and making it a superior edition to boot.  Hey, they even took my suggestion of putting the film on one BD50 instead of two BD25s (the 40th is still a 2-disc set, but now that second disc is just the extras), sparing us the hassle of switching discs mid-film.  I'm a little bummed about the lossy mono mix, but overall, this is better than I was expecting.  Maybe for the 50th, we can get a UHD with lossless mono and an interview with Diane Keaton?  Then we'd really be set and could focus back on the important work of raising the masses out of their accustomed lethargy and the subterranean fires that continue to smoulder.

The Definitive Taxi Driver

Martin Scorsese's masterpiece, Taxi Driver, has been restored in 4k and released as such on blu for a long time now.  But it's only available on an actual 4k Ultra HD disc now, exclusively as a part of the Columbia Classics Vol. 2 boxed set.  It seems like a surprisingly popular title to hide away in an over one hundred dollar collection, but most of the titles from Vol. 1 are still only available in 4k via that set, so I guess this is how it's going to be for a while.
Even 45 years later, Taxi Driver still digs under the skin to probe facets of human nature few other films have even thought to hint at, marking it as one of the indisputable pinnacles of cinematic art; and this is coming from someone who's seen The Killing of Satan.  Writer Paul Schrader and the Mean Streets team proved ideal collaborators, and all the other elements managed to fall just perfectly into place.  There's Bernard Herrmann's final score, NYC's inimitable personality, and all the brilliant supporting players including Albert Brooks, Young Frankenstein's Peter Boyle, a very young Jodie Foster and yes, that's Maniac's own Joe Spinell in that shot above.  People give Cybill Shepard a hard time, but every note she hits is as pitch perfect as everyone else's here.  Obviously, there's a huge pool of talent behind and in front of the camera here (it's easy to forget how powerful an actor DeNiro was when you see all the silly stuff he's committed himself to in recent years), but the planets still had to align just right to achieve these results.
Columbia Tri-Star first released Taxi Driver as an anamorphic widescreen, but completely barebones DVD in 1997.  A disappointing half step backwards for owners of Criterion's special edition laserdisc.  They had to've realized that was pretty paltry, and released a souped-up collector's edition in 1999.  It still didn't have the Criterion commentary, but it had an impressive documentary.  They improved on that further in 2007, with a 2-disc Collector's Edition, this time with a wealth of new extras.  Then it was HD time, and in 2011 came their first Taxi Driver blu-ray.  They released it again in 2013 as a surprisingly barebones "mastered in 4k edition."  It wasn't until 2016 when they really got it right with the 40th Anniversary 2-disc set, which had the 4k master in HD and all the previous extras, including for the first time since laserdisc, that Criterion commentary.  And that was the definitive edition, until now, as Sony has released an ultimate 3-disc set in their Columbia Classics Vol. 2 box, with the film finally on true 4k Ultra HD, plus standard blu and with all the past extras (yes, including the Criterion commentary again).  This is it, assuming they didn't screw anything up.
1) 1999 DVD; 2) 2016 BD; 3) 2021 BD; 4) 2021 UHD.
So yes, like I said before, this film has been restored in 4k for a long time.  In fact, the Columbia Classic book tells us the OCN got its 4k scan back in 2010, and this latest release is still presenting that same restoration, albeit newly color timed for HDR on the UHD.  But first we have a slightly pillar-boxed, distinctly pre-4k 1.75:1 DVD.  The resolution doesn't matter so much when we're talking about a transfer that's going to get mushed down to standard def anyway, and the framing really isn't too different from the properly matted 1.85:1 BDs and UHD (just a little off the left and a bit of extra headroom).  As far as DVDs go, it's fine except for the heavy red push over the whole picture.  So it's nice to see that get corrected along with the much clearer HD boost of the BDs, and again, the minor framing correction.  There's also a slight vertical stretching that gets fixed.  But for 1999, you could've done a lot worse.

Now, the 2016 and 2021 BDs are exactly the same, right down to the 27.1GB encode.  But what's new is the UHD.  Yes, it's the same root transfer.  And it's also true that the previous BD's encode kicks ass, finely capturing grain without the frequent macroblocking.  But look at any portion of any of the UHD screenshots, and the grain is so much clearer and more distinct.  In terms of detail, there's not a lot more to pull out, but in terms of the image matching the original film as opposed to a pixelated digitization, the UHD really succeeds.  The only question is if you'll notice it in motion.  Like, just how big is your TV?  But the difference is there when you look closely enough.
The DVD just features the original audio in 2.0, but it's got a bunch (6) of subtitle options, including English.  The 2016 blu replaces that audio with a DTS-HD 5.1 remix, and adds 11 lossy foreign dubs and offers 22 subtitle tracks, including standard English and English HoH.  So here's where the UHD gets good again.  It adds a couple more foreign dubs and subs, keeps the lossless 5.1 mix, but best of all, it brings back the original mono mix - lossless for the very first time.
So the DVD starts us off with a feature length documentary that talks to just about everybody: Deniro, Scorsese, Foster, Brooks, Schrader, Sheppard, etc.  It's pretty great, and honestly, if this was Taxi Driver's only special feature anywhere, that'd be pretty fine.  The DVD has a couple other odds and ends, including the trailer, storyboards and most interestingly, a 9-minute photo gallery with an uncredited audio commentary by the DVD producer who relays all the interesting anecdotes that didn't make it into the doc.

Jumping ahead to the 2016 doc and the 2021 set (which have all the same extras, except the UHD adds a 20th Anniversary rerelease trailer), we now have everything.  Well except for that photo gallery commentary, but all of those anecdotes wind up getting told, and often retold, in the other extras.  In fact, it's kind of a real problem.  With the Criterion commentary restored, we now have three commentaries, the doc, seven featurettes, an intro by Scorsese, a 40th Anniversary reunion panel, five galleries and two trailers, plus the notes in the book.  So we here the same stories repeated again and again.  By the third or fourth time, it's no longer cute to hear how DeNiro drove a taxi in NY for a week to prepare for the role and was recognized by another actor.  I just wish someone who was overseeing these releases paid attention to what was in these extras and edited how all the redundancy... because there is a wealth of great stuff here, talking to pretty much everybody, revisiting the shooting locations, go over Scorsese's entire career, and even a few weird odds and ends, like a featurette where they interview working NYC cab drivers or talk to Ed Koch.  Some of that's a little excessive, too.  All told, it's both terrific and a real slog, but at least erring towards too much beats erring towards too little.
If you want the best, this is it.  The increased resolution and HDR give us the most authentic picture yet, if you have the set-up to appreciate it.  And even if you don't, getting the original mono track back is a nice little coup for the purists.  Or if you need Icelandic subtitles... those are only on the new UHD.  It may be annoying that this is only available in the box, but fortunately, the whole set is more than worth it.  Could be a good Christmas present for yourself.