Werner Herzog's Fire Within Finally On Blu!

Is it too soon to make an M.I.A. post about this movie?  I guess I wanted to get in ahead of the movie languishing for several years in complete neglect for once.  There's no sign of a physical release, current or pending, in any region, and it's already been available to stream for several months now, despite very few people seeming to be aware that it's done and it's out.  So maybe if there's any chance of having an influence on getting this movie properly released somewhere, anywhere, it's worth speaking up while the film is still fresh?

I'm talking about Werner Herzog's latest documentary, 2022's The Fire Within: A Requiem for Katia and Maurice Krafft.  Yes, it's another volcano movie, following La Soufrière and Into the Inferno, but this one might be the most powerful and compelling yet, in part because it has just as much in common with Grizzly Man as those other two.  This is another story about, in this case, two people who filmed their own deaths following their dangerous obsessions, and capturing unique, beautiful and fascinating film along the way.

Update 9/9/22 - 10/28/26: Yay, another M.I.A. tag baleeted!  It took a few more years than it should've, but we finally got The Fire Within on disc, by way of France.
Maurice and Katia Krafft were French volcanologists who spent their lives traveling to active volcanoes to film their eruptions and the aftermath.  So we have access to footage of decades worth of exotic locales, wild close-up footage of massive volcanic activity and fascinating visuals from their global travels, all heading to another major tragedy the Kraffts (and others) wound up being done in by what they were chasing.  I say "access to footage" because this is essentially a compilation of footage the Kraffts shot, and some by a nearby Japanese videographer during the eruption that took them, rather than original material by Herzog himself.  Herzog only shot one brief scene in Alsace.  But he (and editor Marco Capalbo) shaped the footage into Herzog's vision, which he then narrates.  The way it lingers on beautiful shots of nature and zeroes in on the unusual really makes this feel like a Herzog film, moreso even than some of his other recent docs, like say Lo and Behold, which at times has the tone of a more conventional documentary.  Not this one, especially the way it marries the footage to the music of Ernst Reijseger (Wind Blue Yonder, Salt and Fire, etc).
Of course, you can't talk about Fire Within without at least mentioning that Fire Of Love, another documentary about the Kraffts and using their footage, was released the same year.  This one's narrated by Miranda July, and I guess you'd say it's a more personal, romantic take on the couple and their art, taking more from television interviews, adding little animations (I could've done without those, to be honest) and speculating more about the relationship.  Herzog is actually surprisingly critical in his commentary, repeatedly pointing out how some shots have been staged or "faked for the camera," citing the flaws in their techniques and even attacks the the chairs they sit on during their downtime: "the Kraffts apparently found it cool to use pathetic looking inflatable seats."  But he also admires and rhapsodically sings the praises of the incredible footage they were able to capture, even expressing his disappointment at not being able to have traveled with them.  So both are good films and in some ways, their differing approaches justify the existence of each.  But on the other hand, the majority of the most spectacular footage is central to both and seeing either will make the other feel like a very repetitive experience.  Most audiences, therefore, will probably just pick one, like last year's simultaneous Fyre Festival docs, or Hulu and HBO's dueling Nxivm exposes.  And in that case, yes, I'd recommend Herzog's.
For that matter, the Krafft's volcano footage has appeared in a number of television documentaries over the years, including one about them in 1987 called The Volcano Watchers.  Even Herzog fans might find this stuff familiar, since he devoted a brief segment of Into the Inferno to the Kraffts and their work.  But you'd be doing yourself a serious disservice by skipping this just because you've already seen either of those.  Especially now that you have a better option to view it, as Potemkine (the same label that released that massive Eric Rohmer boxed set years ago) have finally released the film on blu in France, under the title A cœur des volcans: Requiem pour Katia et Maurice Krafft.
2025 Potemkine BD.
So this film looks pretty great in HD.  If you've streamed this on Amazon, it's virtually identical, though the blu offers a tighter encode, while the stream is slightly smoother, but not in a way you'd notice without zooming in close to scrutinize matching screenshots.  The color timing, gamma levels, etc are all identical.  Both present the film in 1.78:1, and the quality naturally varies throughout the film as it's compiled from footage shot by different cameramen with different equipment over the span of decades.  Most of it seems to have been in 16mm, with minimal but noticeable film damage, and there are a couple modern shots of Japan which are much sharper and but also a bit interlaced.  We're mostly looking at great looking old film, however.

Potemkine gives us the original English 5.1 mix in DTS-HD as well as a stereo French dub track also in DTS-HD (yes, it's a different narrator).  The one down-side of this disc: French subtitles are forced for the English track.  They're not burnt in, so if you have a player that can hide unwanted subs, that works perfectly here.  But you should definitely know before going in; that's the weak point here.
But swinging the pendulum back towards the positive, this edition has some nice extras, the most important of which are English-friendly.  The biggest one is an almost half hour interview with Herzog and producer Julien Dumont.  It's a great talk.  Then, also of interest is a shorter interview with Herzog and his editor, showing you a piece of the film as they work on it.  There are a couple more features, but unfortunately, they're not English friendly.  Dumont does an interview in the Krafft's archives, and there's a German language, French subtitled copy of Herzog's short La Soufrière.  The latter is a nice inclusion, especially since Herzog and Dumont talk about it during their interview, and it turns out to have an interesting connection to this film (besides "they're both about volcanoes), but not having it translated isn't such a bummer since it's already received multiple releases with English subs.
So yes, the subtitles are annoying (unless you have a player that can hide unwanted subs, which I can attest works perfectly here).  But they're not too distracting, since much of this film plays to just music anyway.  And considering there's no other option, I definitely wouldn't let them put me off the disc.  It helps, too, that the interviews turned out to be in English - I wasn't expecting that.

2 comments:

  1. I can’t believe that this world class documentary is still not available to purchase in a physical format

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Agree! The last whole bunch of Herzog films have been depressingly absent on home video. Hopefully somebody eventually gathers up all his recent works in a nice box set one of these days.

      Delete