Criterion Breaks Into 4k UHDs with David Lynch's Mulholland Drive

a little pilot-only scene and character
Mulholland Drive seemed to be a comeback film for David Lynch. He got an Academy Award nomination as Best Director for it, despite or perhaps partially because of its long and painful birth process. It was originally shot as a ninety-odd minute television pilot for ABC. A sort of second Twin Peaks. But the network ultimately declined it, and it never aired. A year or two later, Lynch teamed up with the French film company Studio Canal to buy it from ABC bring back the cast, and film all new material to flush it out into a feature film and a complete, self-contained story (the pilot, naturally, was left open-ended, as it was meant to lead into an entire series worth of events).

So it played well theatrically, and eventually in 2002, Universal gave us the slightly controversial DVD. Thanks to Lynch's eccentricity and probably a slight misunderstanding of the medium, it is presented without chapter stops, as per his wishes. As a pleasant surprise, however, it turns out the DVD does have chapter stops, a lot even, they're just not indicated by a chapters menu. But they're there. It also doesn't have any special features (despite some good, on-set interviews being available, as we'll come to later) except for a single page insert with "10 Clues to Unlocking This Thriller." And finally, Lynch personally censored one scene from the film for its home video release. A brief shot of Laura Herring, featuring some below the belt nudity, was optically fogged despite playing uncut in theaters, apparently to prevent nude photos from circulating on the internet.

Meanwhile, in Europe, Studio Canal released a 2-disc special edition. And in 2010, they even upgraded it to blu-ray, something which has yet to happen in the states. So, not for the first time, Lynch fans were compelled to import.

Update: 4/30/15 - 4/6/17 - 5/8/17 - 6/8/17: There is no end!  The Criterion blu did come out, so I updated this post with that.  Then I updated it with the Concorde blu, and now I'm updating it yet again with the new Studio Canal blu (not to be confused with the previous Studio Canal blu).  This one creates even more new special features and uses the updated 4k scan that debuted on the Criterion disc.  Is it the ultimate, definitive Mulholland Drive release?  Is it worth replacing an older edition for?  Let's solve the mystery.

Update 11/17/21: I'm about fed up with updating Mulholland Drive editions, but how could I say no when they've updated an entire format?  Yes, Mulholland Drive has finally been released as a 4k Ultra HD disc (with a standard BD as well).  And it's from Criterion.  They've finally caved to fan demand and started releasing UHDs.  This is an exciting day!
Mulholland Drive is pretty great, but even as a big Lynch fan, I do have minor issues with it. They mostly boil down to what I see as the more conventional characters and story points: like the stuff with the hitmen and the director's subplot. I can't say what was in the writers' heads, of course, but I suspect these elements are concessions for more mainstream television viewers who wouldn't appreciate Lynch's usual work, and as such is more archetypal and less humanistic and compelling than, say, his next film, Inland Empire, even though it's a far less popular work of his. At any rate, even if that's not true about why that material is in there, those points give that impression, which comes down to the same thing. But even accepting all of my quibbles, it's still a smart, creative and gripping drama, with all of Lynch's strengths here in force.

So how does it look on blu-ray and how does the DVD stand up against it? And how does each subsequent blu-ray (and UHD) release stack up against its predecessor?  We've got a lot of comparing to do!
1) Universal 2002 DVD 2) Studio Canal 2010 BD; 3) Concorde 2011 BD;
4) Criterion 2015 BD; 5) Studio Canal 2017 BD; 6) Criterion 2021 BD;
7) Criterion 2021 UHD.


So, not a huge difference, but there is an incremental improvement with each release.  Well, except the 2010 Studio Canal and the Concorde.  They're virtually identical.  In fact, Concorde's encode is slightly worse; so it's a tiny step down.  But the older SC blu-ray clears away all the standard def smudginess of the DVD, and Criterion's 2015 4k scan of the OCN smartens up the image with a touch more clarity and noticeably deeper colors.  They'll be slim upgrades to casual viewers, but aficionados will appreciate each generation's step forward.  All seven releases feature a slightly letterboxed 1.85:1 aspect ratio, but the 4k updates have ever so slightly shifted horizontally and vertically.  And then, again, Studio Canal's 2017 blu uses the same 4k scan as the Criterion, so I have to say I'm surprised how distinct it turned out.  There had been rumblings that perhaps Criterion's encoding could be slightly better, and indeed, I'd say it is on the 2017 SC.  Criterion's encoding does leave things like a hint of horizontal lines running across Naomi's upper lip and cheek, for example.  And areas of grain seem patchy, like little pixelated blocks.  This is real magnifying-glass-to-the-monitor stuff, but it's there, and SC does do a better job of not having that problem.  However, what's much more obvious is how much grainier the 2017 SC blu looks.  It looks like Criterion tried to de-grain the image a bit, whereas SC let it all hang out, which perfectionists always prefer.

But anyone who's looking that close, or whose screen is big enough, can forget all about which BD is better.  Because the UHD obviously boosts the resolution to a whole new level.  It's a new Dolby Vision transfer, made in conjunction with SC and, according to the booklet, "based on the 2015 color transfer."  So it's boosted to HDR and in true 4k now (you can really see jagged edges turned smooth and natural when you zoom in close), but still holding to the spirit of the previous restorations, as supervised by Lynch.  Therefor, it's interesting to note that the BD in the new 2021 set doesn't even use the new 2021 transfer at all; it's still their 2015, even in terms of how it captures/ retains grain.  So SC's 2017 BD is actually still better than Criterion's 2021 BD; and if you can't play UHDs, the SC is still the blu to stick with.  But of course, if you can play it, Criterion's UHD is the best this film has ever looked.
2010 Studio Canal blu-ray on top; bootleg DV-R of the pilot below
So now there's nothing to be gained from noting that the blu-ray trumps the DV-R of the TV pilot. That's just a low quality bootleg. There is no legit release of the pilot version, so don't run yourself ragged searching. It's no great loss, anyway, since there's very little in the pilot that's not in the film... It's mostly the other way around: there's a lot in the film that's missing in the pilot. But I thought it was worth posting the comparison because we see that, naturally, the 90s television image is full-frame. And since it was shot for TV first and converted to cinema second, Lynch clearly matted the 4:3 image down. So that means in the lower image you're seeing the image open matte, with a lot more picture on the top and bottom; and that's the way it was originally composed to be viewed. It's the OAR, at least for the footage that wasn't added later.

Speaking of interesting, alternate presentations of the footage, The 2015 Criterion release is the first uncensored presentation of the film, and yes, Studio Canal's 2017 blu follows suit.  As you may've already been familiar with, Lynch himself blurred a scene of full frontal nudity for the home video release (that played uncensored in the original theatrical run) around the 99 minute mark.  It was already a heavily shadowed scene, so casual viewers wouldn't even notice, but a distinct blur was put over Jeanne Bates Laura Harring in one bedroom scene, and that was on the original US DVD, the 2010 Studio Canal blu, the Concorde blu and pretty much every other version.  But by going back to the original film elements for their new 4k scan, Criterion bypassed it (sorry, no screenshot, kids).  And yes, it's still uncensored on the UHD.

As for audio options, the Universal DVD gave us a choice between DTS 5.1 and Dolby Digital 5.1 mixes, but all four blus and the UHD simply give us uncompressed DTS-HD 5.1 tracks.  Well, Concorde also has a German DTS-HD 5.1 and 2010 Studio Canal gives us Spanish and French DTS-HD 5.1s (2017 SC keeps the French, but drops the Spanish).  They also include Dutch, French and Italian subtitles, while Concorde just have German subs and the original DVD has French and Spanish subtitles.  Only the Criterions and new Studio Canal actually give us (optional) English subtitles... at least for the main feature.
But what about the extras? Like I said, the DVD had nothing, not even the trailer. Just that insert with "clues." The Studio Canal blu-ray trumps even the insert by including a 20 page booklet, which, yes, includes the clues. But there's also some real, meaty extras on the blu as well:

• Introduction by Thierry Jousse - A ten minute lead in by filmmaker Jousse. This, like several of the extras, are in French, but everything's fully subtitled for English viewers.

• In the Blue Box - A 28 minute featurette where a bunch of filmmakers (the guy who directed Donnie Darko, the director of Colt 45, etc) talk about the film and their experiences with it.

• On the Road To Mulholland Drive - a 24 minute 'making of' documentary, primarily based on interviews with Lynch, Naomi Watts and Laura Herring, inter-cutting between them with some nice behind the scenes B-roll footage. This one's been around a while, even my pilot bootleg DVD has it on there, and was mostly or entirely shot during filming. One wonders why this was left off the Universal DVD. I guess Lynch just didn't want there to be any extras on that?

• Interview with Mary Sweeny - A short but interesting talk with the film's co-producer and editor.

• Interview with Angelo Badalamenti - A little under twenty minutes with the film's composer, who also plays a small role, from around the time of the film's release.

• Interview with Angelo Badalamenti - Yes, another one. But this one's newly recorded, and it's audio only. It's about 17 minutes and unfortunately repeats a lot of anecdotes nearly word for word from the previous interview. There are some unique bits, so it's still worth watching, but one wishes Studio Canal would've edited out all the duplicate material.

• Back to Mulholland Drive - A 24 minute featurette that focuses on the mysteries of the film and decoding its more symbolic meanings. It includes some additional interview footage of Lynch, and explains the 10 clues, which is nice, because as written they're not illuminating at all, even when you pretty much get the film. Overall, it's a pretty compelling extra, but it's a little silly and I think they arrive at precisely the wrong conclusion about one of the clues. But for the most part, it pretty much explains and clarifies everything for people who saw the movie and felt they didn't understand any of it. And even if you feel you've got everything worked out, you probably didn't catch all of the little hints and touches they point out.
That was pretty awesome, but now Criterion is here to enter the races!  They've got a healthy collection of special features, too; and they're mostly all new.

• Interview with David Lynch and Naomi Watts - Finally, a proper interview with Lynch on this film besides those vintage promo clips. And here he's alongside star Watts for a really engaging talk.

• New interviews with Justin Theroux, Laura Harring, Naomi Watts and casting director Johanna Ray - A substantial featurette with several of the stars that runs well over half and hour.

• Interview with Angelo Badalamenti - Yes, this is different than the two on the Studio Canal discs, running just under 20 minutes, though he doesn't really say anything he didn't say before.

• Interviews with Peter Deming and Jack Fisk - We get to hear from a couple key people we haven't yet, the cinematographer and production designer.

• On-set footage - About 24 minutes worth of behind-the-scenes footage.  We saw a lot of this in On the Road To Mulholland Drive, but this is basically just the raw, B-roll footage without the framing interviews.

• Deleted scene - Robert Forster at the police station.  I'm surprised they didn't put in all the other material from the pilot - it would've been great to see it restored from film elements, too - but maybe Lynch didn't want it included?

• Trailer

Criterion's release also includes a 48-page booklet, with an interview with Lynch from the book Lynch on Lynch.  And it comes packaged in a stylish fold-out digipack that fits inside a sturdy slipbox.  Overall, both blus have some nice, exclusive stuff.  But overall, I definitely have to give the win to Criterion's collection.  Or I did at the time.
Concorde?  That's the whole reason I tracked this blu down and, well, it's pretty disappointing.  I mean, taken on its own, it's okay.  It sure trumps the DVD.
• Making of featurette - This is actually the On the Road To Mulholland Drive doc.  Still a good little doc, but nothing new if you have any of the other releases.

• Interviews - Interviews with Watts, Lynch, Harring and Theroux.  These are actually the exact same interview clips that appear in On the Road.  That's right; it's the same stuff on the disc twice.  I guess the benefit is this lets you jump right to certain interview clips without watching the whole, 23 minute doc?  Meh.

• 3 TV spots

• Trailer - Surprisingly, only this and the Criterion disc have this.  The old DVD and both Studio Canal releases are missing it.

• German trailer

And it has a couple of bonus German-dubbed trailers.  Pretty disappointing.  I figured the 'making of' doc would turn out to be On the Road again.  But I figured the interviews had to be some exclusive press junket clips or something.  Who knew they'd have the audacity to just reuse the same footage twice?  Oh well.
Studio Canal really went for it this time.  They've got new extras, previous Studio Canal extras, they've got Concorde extras and they've even got Criterion extras.  But they still don't have everything...

• Introduction by Thierry Jousse - As carried over from the previous Studio Canal disc.

• Interview with David Lynch and Naomi Watts - I was surprised to see this one here; it's the one Criterion made for their release.  Sweet!

• New interview with Laura Harring - Even sweeter, some brand new content.  A nicely edited, 14-minute on-camera piece.

• Interview with Mary Sweeny - This is from the previous Studio Canal disc, still quite good.

• Back to Mulholland Drive - The look at the mysteries from the previous Studio Canal disc.

• In the Blue Box - Again, this is from the previous Studio Canal disc.  But don't take that as dismissive comment.  I'm glad they kept all these goodies.

• On the Road To Mulholland Drive - This is the vintage 'making of' that's been on every release except the original DVD.

• EPK Interviews - These are the same, short interview clips with Watts, Lynch, Harring and Theroux that were on the Concorde disc; basically the remaining soundbites that weren't heard in On the Road.

• Interview with Angelo Badalamenti - This is the one from the older Studio Canal disc; the video one.  The audio-only one was not ported over.

• On-set footage - About 24 minutes worth of behind-the-scenes footage.  We saw a lot of this in On the Road To Mulholland Drive, but this is basically just the raw, B-roll footage without the framing interviews.

• Deleted scene - The same Robert Forster scene from the Criterion disc.

So, this may well be the best collection of extras, but even though they brought over the Lynch/ Watts talk, they're still missing a couple featurettes from the Criterion: the interviews with cinematographer Peter Deming and production designer Jack Fisk, the cast featurette interviewing Justin Theroux, Laura Harring, Naomi Watts and Johanna Ray, the on-set footage featurette and their interview with Badalamenti.  And they've dropped the audio-only interview with Badalamenti from their own previous release.  Given how redundant it was, that makes some sense, but it seems odd they'd lose one of their own special features.  Frankly though, the biggest losses are the interviews with Fisk, Deming and Ray, as their voices aren't included anywhere else.  Also, bizarrely, it's missing the trailer.  Why do so many releases of this film keep forgetting the trailer?  But still, the trailer's just the trailer.  In 2017, Studio Canal's assembled a very strong mesh of the best of all the previous releases that's tough to beat.  Also, this release comes in a slip cover and includes six cardstock art cards that you can see in the photo above.

And Criterion's 2021 UHD/ BD set?  Finally a simple answer: exactly the same extras as their 2015 release.  The same book, slipbox (albeit with UHD markings, natch) and everything.
What was once a tough call has been made easy.  Criterion's UHD is the best presentation of this film.  But fans will probably want to hang onto their SC discs for the (mostly) unique set of extras.  Yes, there's some overlap and redundancy (how many Badalamenti interviews does one need?), but SC and Criterion both have some compelling, unique stuff.  You won't need any of the older releases after that, unless you're a real completist and want to hold onto the old Studio Canal release for the audio-only Badalamenti interview (but, like I just said...).

Maniac Cop 3: Shiny, New Badge of Silence

Man, the wait for Blue Underground to finally regain the rights to release the Maniac Cop sequels the right way has been a long, highly anticipated one. For ages, we've had nothing but cheap-o, barebones DVD releases, which is pretty rare for William Lustig and Larry Cohen films, especially two of their most popular. But at least First Look's DVD of Maniac Cop 3 was widescreen, with a decent picture. Maniac Cop 2 was fullscreen. And considering Maniac Cop 3 is the one the filmmakers disavowed anyway, 3 was the less crucial of the two. But as soon as its pre-order was up, I still jumped on.

Update 10/5/15 - 11/11/21: And when the pre-order for the latest UHD/ BD 2-disc combo came up, I jumped again!  It sure doesn't feel like it's been eight years since the last edition, but it's been at least long enough that I'm happy to triple-dip.
Even if the control of the film hadn't been wrested away from Lustig and Cohen by the producers with changes made against their will (Larry's left his on, but Lustig took his name off the picture), I still think it would've been the weakest entry. Suddenly we've got voodoo and Cordell spends half the picture stalking around a hospital like a generic slasher. But if you look past the problems, it's a pretty fun movie regardless. It's got lots of witty Cohen moments and some spectacular action sequences (or at least one super-mega one at the finale) by Lustig. Robert Davi returns as the lead, supported by some more great character actors in the minor roles; and the "Bride of Maniac Cop" angle is fun in a B-movie kind of way. It doesn't do the best job of standing up against the first two films, but viewed as just a little, low budget horror flick in a vacuum, it's pretty enjoyable.

Now, it's worth noting that there was a slightly trimmed R-rated cut and a full unrated cut released on video back in the day. I think the R-rated cut may have even seen its way onto DVD in the past. But both the BU and First Look releases contain the uncut unrated version, so you're pretty safe.
1) 2004 FL DVD; 2) 2013 BU DVD; 3) 2013 BU BD;
4) 2021 BU BD; 5) 2021 BU UHD.




A big revelation that came with Blue Underground's 2013 release: it's now framed at 2.35:1. I never would've guessed it was originally shot for that ratio... First Look's DVD is anamorphic 1.78:1, and it looks pretty natural. Heck, it was originally released as a TV movie on HBO, where it played 1.33:1; but I do believe it was shot with widescreen in mind. I'd always just assumed that it was meant to be slightly matted down to 1.85:1. But the 2.35:1 isn't giving us any extra picture on the sides, it's just doing a lot of vertical cropping. There are close ups where people's chins drop out of frame whenever they talk.
First Look DVD left, Blue Underground 2013 blu-ray right.
But it's been confirmed again with the new 2021 release, and Lustig himself says he shot it 2.35 in the extras. So I guess we can put that question to rest.  And of course, framing aside, there's no question Blue Underground's BDs are far superior in all other aspects. Even the 2013 blu is a much cleaner, clearer HD image with more vivid and darker colors (First Look's blacks are faded gray, not actual black), and it's just so much more attractive to look at. Even the DVD included in BU's first combo package handles the SD compression better than First Look.

Then we come to the 2021 edition, and it's an all new, 4k scan from the original negative.  It's actually even wider now, at 2.39:1, but that's revealing a bit more along the sides than cropping even tighter.  The framing's even been adjusted a smidgen (to catch those chins!).  I'd say it's an improvement, but surely what you're noticing isn't the AR but the much richer colors.  They've really re-timed this picture.  And it's not a case of "HDR crayons," as it's that way on the BD, too.  It's certainly a more attractive, colorful image, and Lustig is enthusiastic about how it looks on the commentary, so if it's revisionist (and he admits he has made some little tweaks along the way), it's at least the filmmakers' own handiwork.  Grain and finer points already looked pretty good on the 2013 disc, but the UHD resolution takes away digital pixelation when you get in close.  Admittedly, it reveals more smooth grain texture than actual fine detail, but there's no question it's a more natural, filmic image now in 4k.

First Look had Spanish subtitles and a stereo audio track, which was nice; but BU kicked it in the teeth with their 2013 BD, including a 5.1 DTS-HD track, an admittedly lossy 2.0 stereo track, and a whopping ten different subtitle tracks, including English. It's also enhanced for D-Box motion control systems, if you're one of the five people on Earth who has a use for that.  And in 2021?  The 5.1 has been turned into a new Dolby Atmos track, and that stereo mix is now lossless DTS-HD.  All the subs are still there, and so is the D-Box.
And extras, yes. I was a pleasantly surprised the First Look DVD had the trailer, which Blue Underground also has. But of course Blue Underground's 2013 release has substantially more. Although, actually, it doesn't have an audio commentary, which you'd expect from Lustig and Cohen, especially on Lustig's own label. This is not the loaded special edition I'd anticipated. But it does have some good stuff, the crown jewel of which is a 25-minute 'making of' featurette. It's not afraid to tell the real, not entirely happy story of the film, and includes interviews with Lustig. Cohen, Davi, Robert Z'Dar, DoP Jacques Haitkin, Caitlin Dulany, Gretchen Becker and stuntman Spiro Razatos. There are several deleted scenes, too, which are a treat to see, and a photo gallery, plus it comes in a slipcover.

The 2021 release keeps all of that, and now it finally has a commentary "with Director Alan Smithee."  That's Lustig, of course, and he's joined by Joel Soisson, the producer who directed the rest of the scenes after Lustig walked off.  They're on good terms now, but this is as frank and candid a discussion about what went wrong, as well as right, as you could ever want.  Lustig always does great commentaries, and this is one for the ages.  And it comes housed in a stylish, embossed slipcover.
Maniac Cop 3 is a better film then it gets credit for, even if it's not as strong as the other two. And Blue Underground's UHD is the new definitive release, even if the purist in me winces at the little alterations.  Lustig has now given us stellar 4k editions of parts 2 and 3... let's just hope the original can find its way home to him, now, for the perfect trilogy.

The Howling: Restored

We have another somewhat early Scream Factory release, but by point, they had about 15-20 discs behind them.  It's Joe Dante's The Howling, and I was already on board for this release just because it's a bit of a horror classic, and this was our chance to finally get it in HD, with all the old extras, plus a bunch of new ones.  So I didn't bother reading updates or reviews for this disc, I just bought it on faith.  And it wound up not only to living up to my expectations, but it was a nice little surprise.

Update 9/5/116 - 11/9/21: The Howling was an older Scream Factory blu based on an even older MGM master.  This film was itself howling for an update, and Studio Canal have delivered.  And it's not just an upgraded blu with a fresh scan, which I would've thrilled with, it's a 4k Ultra HD release, with multiple discs in fancy packaging, new extras and everything you could ask for!  But is there anything off about it?
The Howling's always a pleasant surprise for me every time I revisit it anyway.  Some time goes by and I forget all the details, and I start to think of it as an okayish werewolf movie that was overshadowed by An American Werewolf In London and spawned some of the worst follow-ups in horror franchise history.  But then I rewatch it and I'm hit by it all again.  On the one hand, it's a quirky, fun play on all the traditional motifs with Dante's usual sense of humor, from Forrest Ackerman's appearance to the old Hollywood references, as if he'd made Piranha 2: This Time They're Werewolves (the less said about the actual Piranha 2 the better).  But this time it's based on the Gary Brandner novel, which gives it a serious heft to it, a dark side to take seriously.  Even when Paul Bartel was getting attacked by the killer fish and his life was really in danger, everything felt like it was all in fun.  But when Robert Picardo comes creeping after Dee Wallace, there's a real threatening vibe there.  It's a real roller coaster ride, diving from cute to disturbing and then rising back up to charming but never completely safe.
It isn't quite on Gremlins' level yet, but Dante's got a real studio budget behind him, and it shows.  It has a variety of great effects, and a killer cast including Patrick Macnee, John Carradine, Kevin McCarthy, Slim Pickens, and fun cameos by Dick Miller, John Sayles (who also worked on this screenplay) and Roger Corman.  It isn't 100% faithful to the novel, but honestly, I think it's better for it.  I never read the book, but I read Howling II as a kid and I just remember being really bored, like when is a werewolf ever going to attack somebody?  Plus, Howling 4 went back and did a completely faithful adaptation, and look how that turned out.  So I think this is a case of both creators lifting the other up to be better than they'd be on their own.  Or maybe John Sayles carried the pair of them.  Both theories are equally plausible to me.  But the point is, something really clicked in The Howling.
So The Howling was originally released on DVD by MGM in 2000, but their 2003 special edition reissue has been pretty much the default Howling DVD for years and years. DVD of course being standard def, though, so it was only a matter of time until it hit blu-ray and HD, and in the US, that came to us via Scream Factory's 2013 special edition.  Now, we all know the drill with Scream Factory and MGM.  They've been going through their whole horror catalog, licensing a ton of great titles and using MGM's HD master without doing additional restoration, regardless of the original master's quality - that's what led to the Ravenous disappointment.  But now in 2021, we don't have to stress over any of that, because Studio Canal has released it as a restored, 2-(or 3-, depending which edition you bought... we'll come back to that)disc 4k Ultra HD release with an all new scan.
1) MGM widescreen DVD; 2) MGM fullscreen DVD;
3) Scream Factory BD; 4) Studio Canal BD; 5) Studio Canal UHD.




Okay, well first of all, I forgot to mention: MGM's DVD was a flipper disc, with an open matte fullscreen version on the back.  So that's kind of fun to look at.  But don't let that distract you now; check out the widescreen DVD and the SF shots.  That's a totally different master!  The DVD is redder and the blu is greener, for a start.  But more compelling than that, check out the extra information on the blu-ray's sides.  The blu-ray is at the proper 1.85:1 aspect ratio, but the DVD's just at a weird 1.80.  And of course, that's in addition to the expected benefit of boosting the picture to HD.  Look how much more readable those magazine covers are now.  Would you have ever been able to make out "Fingers Become Claws" on the DVD?  Heck, the difference is even more extreme on his hand.  it actually looks like they might've used a little sharpening or something when you get in this close, but not to the point where it's an issue.  Overall, it's a bigger upgrade than I was expecting.

But, of course, SC's upgrade is even bigger.  First of all, it's still exactly 1.85:1, but it is revealing even a slight bit more around the edges.  But SF's old master really screams when you look at the film grain.  It's a mushy mess, whereas even SC's BD is fine and distinct, let alone their actual 4k UHD.  And a big part of the improvement is a benefit of not having the tinkering the old blu does.  Look at, for example, the writing on the bottom of that Famous Monsters magazine cover.  The tiny writing, which, even on the UHD is a struggle to make out.  One thing that makes it even harder to decipher on the SF disc, though, is all that black noise.  What is that?  That's an attempt at sharpening the old master, to separate the yellow from the dark blue background.  It also turns some of the yellow white, to make it further stand out.  That maybe, arguably is a successful effect when you're seeing it on a much smaller screen compressed to SD.  It made sense for the DVD.  But for the BD, it was just unwanted noise, and there was no way it could stand on a UHD.  Thankfully, SC's new transfer is free of all of that.  It also has much subtler highlights and more natural color timing (i.e., Dennis Dugan's face is no longer tinted blue).  This is a bigger leap forward than most BDs to UHDs, both because SC did a first class job and because the previous master was troubled.

Audio-wise, all three releases do it right, giving you the choice between a 5.1 mix and the original mono (both lossless on each of the BDs and UHD).  And they all have optional English subtitles.  For non-English speakers, MGM also has French and Spanish subtitles, while SC has lossless French and German dubs and subs.
And like I was saying, the MGM was already pretty nicely decked out with extras.  It has the old laserdisc commentary with Dante, Picardo, Stone and actor Christopher Stone.  They joke around a lot, but still manage to get in a good deal of memories and insight.  There's a substantial, almost hour-long 'making of' documentary called Unleashing the Beast that interviews almost everybody, including Dante, Sayles, Stone, Picardo, Miller, Belinda Belaski, producer Mike Finnell and DOP John Hora, plus Macnee is included by way of a vintage television interview And it's also got fifteen minutes of deleted scenes and outtakes, the vintage promo featurette, 2 galleries, 2 trailers, some bonus trailers, and an insert with liner notes.  Plus, hidden away as an easter egg, is a brief bonus interview with Dick Miller.
So it really didn't seem like The Howling could use anymore special features, but Scream Factory proved that idea wrong.  First of all, everything from the MGM special edition is carried over, even the easter egg Miller interview (making this one of the very few Scream Factory releases with easter eggs).  But then, Scream Factory went and recorded a new, second audio commentary with author Gary Brandner!  He's one of the most important voices that had always been absent from Howling stuff until now, and it's great to hear from him, even though they do unfortunately spend a lot of time covering the general "career overview" ground rather than Howling-specific talk, a direction the moderator seems more responsible for than Brandner.  They also do new, on-camera interviews with pretty much everybody else the documentary missed: effects artist David Allen, co-writer Terrance Winkles, editor Mark Goldblatt and executive producer Steven A. Lane. And last but certainly not least, there's another great episode of Horror's Hallowed Grounds.  It has reversible cover art so you can replace their goofy comic book art with the original poster and a slipcover, though again, it's too bad no one's figured out a way to make reversible slips.

And the Studio Canal?  Unfortunately, it lost most of the legacy extras. Goodbye, commentaries, documentary and Scream Factory interviews.  Goodbye, Horror's Hallowed Grounds.  It does keep a few things, though, like the deleted scenes, outtakes, and the trailer.  But more importantly, there's new stuff.  So how does that add up?  Do they make up for the loss of the old stuff?  Are they essential viewing on their own?  And, well, here's where things get wonky.
technically, this is a shot from Welcome To Werewolfland.
Let's start with this.  Studio Canal has an all new documentary called Welcome To Werewolfland.  Except, it's just barelllllly new.  It's comprised entirely of the same interviews as Unleashing the Beast.  No, it's not the same doc.  It makes different choices, for example Unleashing cuts to a cover of Brandner's novel when it's brought up, Werewolfland doesn't.  That's a minor one, of course.  Werewolfland is actually longer, leaving in bits Unleashing cut out.  For example, in Werewolfland, Dante lists the sequels he's seen and mistakenly says Howling 4 takes place in a castle (he's thinking of Howling 5).  Unleashing removes that line, so he doesn't misspeak.  As a result of these changes, Werewolfland is three minutes longer.  Yay, so it's better!  Right?  Well, not so fast.  Werewolfland cuts out all of John Sayles and David Allen's footage.  I presume this change is purely a legal play around copyrights and licensing fees.  But in the end, I'd say Werewolfland is worse than Unleashing, though if you're an ultra-dedicated, die-hard, completist fan, I'll concede that it means both versions do have a little bit of unique content, so there's value in both.  But really, 90+% of the content is exactly the same.

But it's not all disappointment.  They do have a new featurette interviewing Joe Dante.  And while sure, he says some of the same things about The Howling he says in all the other extras; he also talks rather frankly about some of his later films, fights with the studios, etc, which is quite interesting and not in any previous Howling extra.  And there's more good news.  Yes, MGM, Scream Factory and Studio Canal all feature the same outtakes... except Studio Canal has discovered more.  So there are six additional minutes of never before scene outtakes on SC's release, in addition to all the ones on the older discs.  The only other feature to note is the very stylish steelbook packaging.

...Assuming you bought the 2-disc set.  If you bought the 3-disc set, instead of a steelbook it comes in a slipbox and also includes  20-page booklet, poster and 5 art cards.  And most importantly, it includes a third disc: a DVD of 2015's Creature Designers - The Frankenstein Complex (and some extras associated with that doc).  It's more of an overview of monster effects than anything Howling-specific, but they do talk a bunch about the Howling and talk to Dante.  If you picked up the recent Monster Collection set, or any previous release of The Frankenstein Complex, you don't need this (all of the extras here are also on those), but if you don't, this is a really nice treat.
So Scream Factory's The Howling was an essential release at the time, and they did everything they could to do to make it great, with an improved transfer, both audio tracks and a sweet collection of legacy and additional features.  And unlike Halloween 3, this time they remembered subs.  But it's gotten old, and SC has come to not just take the title but completely revitalize the Howling viewing experience.  This one's a must-upgrade.  But while the extras they do provide may be enough for a casual viewer (even in its Werewolfland form, it's a great doc that tells the film's story really well), the SF has so many great additional extras, it will probably still be essential to hold onto, if only as some kind of fancy bonus disc.  Oh, and speaking of bonuses...

Bonus video: see inside a Howling DVD, literally!

On the Rocks On the Blu

I apologize for the title, but I will not change it.  I have no defense.  It just hit me in the shower and now I'm inexplicably attached.  So let's just move past it together.

I said in my FYC post that this would be a Day 1 pick-up for me, and here it is: Sofia Coppola's latest film, On the Rocks.  The once Apple TV streaming exclusive has now landed on blu from A24/ Lions Gate.  It's come a lot sooner than I would've expected it (or I wouldn't have bothered tracking down that screener), but I'm here for it.  The only reason this review wasn't posted last week is because I wanted to put Halloween 3 up on Halloween.

Update 11/3/22: Just thought I'd quietly add Lions Gate's official DVD release to the mix.
On the Rocks finds Sofia finally dipping herself into adulthood, rather than looking back at lost youth, with Rashida Jones essentially her her first grown up protagonist.  I mean, sure, Stephen Dorff was the lead in Somewhere, but Elle Fanning was obviously the Sofia surrogate that time.  Fan favorite Bill Murray is back, playing a cad: essentially his trademark character from films like Ghostbusters and Stripes, but now in his twilight years.  Imagine that man was your dad.  He walked out on you and your mother in your youth, but now he's back in your life because you were finally ready to reach out and have a relationship with him again once you became a parent yourself.  This is just one of Jones' complicated relationships with men.
The other is with her husband, played surprisingly down to Earth by Marlon Wayans.  His career is taking off while hers is inert, allowing him to stay out late for after-work dinners and fly off on exotic business trips while she plays mommy all day.   The situation's already teetering on midlife crisis when she begins to suspect he's having an affair.  But how to find out for sure?  Suddenly having a world famous womanizer in her corner could prove advantageous... or disastrous.  Murray lectures Jones on men's baser ways and leads her on a series of spy missions as this film turns from character study to Hollywood RomCom.  Half this film's script could be lifted out of a Meg Ryan star vehicle from the 90s.  But that's not entirely a bad thing when the humor works and the stars are classically charismatic.  And Coppola still manages to find lyricism between the gags, landing an ultimately touching if light feature.  It won't go down as one of her masterworks, but it's still an achievement.
1) 2020 Apple/ A24 DVD; 2) 2021 Apple/ LG DVD; 3) 2021 Apple/ LG BD.
As you'd expect, the blu-ray image is clearer and sharper than either DVD.  All the fuzziness around every edge is gone.  And of course, it doesn't have the awful watermarks of the FYC DVD.  Both the LG DVD and BD's 1.85:1 framing also corrects the FYC DVD's, which was stretched slightly to 1.83:1.  It may not look like a huge leap, as they're all sourced from the same master, but finally getting this in HD yields a much more satisfying, uncompromised viewing.  And even the commercial DVD is a slight improvement (even forgetting the watermark).  Also, while all three discs offer the same 5.1 track, it's lossless DTS-HD on the blu.  All three discs also include optional English subtitles, along with Spanish on the DVDs and French on the blu (I know that sounds wrong; you'd think the two Lions Gates would match and the A24 would be the with different subs, but it's correct). 

My heart fluttered when I saw "Special Features" on the menu, but it turned out to be nothing.  Just "Also From A24" bonus trailers for The Green Knight, Zola and Minari.  Not even the On the Rocks trailer.  At least it comes in a nice slipcover.
Still, it's a perfect presentation of the film outside of 4k.  I'm pretty sure it was shot and streams in 4k, so a UHD would've been nice.  But realistically, the blu's all we could expect; I'm not gonna grouse.  I'm happy with a physical copy in HD.  Plus, you can't beat the price - it's list is $17.99, so you can easily get it new for well under that.  Absolutely worth it.