Marx Madness Part 1: The Five Four Marx Brothers

Universal just released the blu-ray debut of Paramount's five Marx Bros. movies - the only five to star the Four Marx Bros, as opposed to the Three - and it's a pretty exciting set.  Besides this being their first time in HD, we've got brand new transfers and all new extras.  And most impressively of all, their second film, Animal Crackers, has been restored to include censored footage not seen since 1936!  This is the new Silver Screen Collection!  ...Not to be confused with Paramount's old Silver Screen Collection of the same five films, which I've also got.  Odd choice to give both sets the same name, but there you go.  Let's see how these released have improved.
In fact, before we start going movie by movie, let me just break down the the multiple Paramount releases. To be clear, these aren't all the Marx Bros movies, but they're always packaged together because these are the five films the Brothers did with Paramount.  After that, they switched movie studios, Zeppo left, and the rest of the Marx Brothers films just feature Groucho, Harpo and Chico.  Those are with a different studio.  These first five films were originally released separately and in a 1999 boxed set by Paramount and Image, which quickly went out of print and used copies tended to sell for crazy amounts of money.  So in 2004, Paramount reissued these in a fancy, shiny silver media book - the first Silver Screen Collection - with slightly remastered transfers and a bonus disc of a few extras.  In 2011, they all each got solo releases, basically just the 2004 discs in single cases.  Then, in 2013, the 2004 Silver Screen Collection was reissued in less fancy packaging.  And now, in 2016, we have the new blu-ray release, the updated Silver Screen Collection, which has the same artwork as the 2013 set.  It's like they're deliberately trying to be confusing, though at least the 2016 set says "Restored Edition" across the top.
2004 Silver Screen DVD on top; 2016 Silver Screen blu-ray bottom.
We begin with 1929's The Cocoanuts.  Technically their second film as their first, a silent entry named Humor Risk, is lost to the world, The Cocoanuts is also the first of two Marx Brothers films directly adapting one of their Broadway hits, scripted by George S. Kaufman and with music by Irving Berlin.  In it, Groucho owns a bankrupt hotel, managed by Zeppo, and they're desperate to sell off some land.  Meanwhile, there's a love triangle going on between Mary Eaton, her good boyfriend, an architect with plans for some of the land, and her bad boyfriend, a high class jewel thief.  And of course we've also got a pair of not-so-high class thieves, Harpo and Chico.  Margaret Dumont's jewels get burgled, Groucho rigs an auction, and Mary teaches us all how to do "The Monkey Doodle Doo." The first two films do feel more stagey than the later films, but unless you're consciously looking for movement and more camera set-ups, it's not a problem.  It doesn't hurt the brothers' comedy, and it doesn't hurt the charming musical numbers.
We start out with a modest but still quite noticeable improvement.  The image is sharper and clearer, which you'll notice more clearly if you click and view the screenshots in full size; and the contrast is a little stronger on the new blu.  A bit of the damage and mess has been cleaned up, too.  A few moments (see the set of shots directly above) have been restored - not for this 2016 edition, but long ago - from a lower quality source and looks it.  Even there, the blu is a little better.  You'll notice the framing is slightly shifted, too; for example, in the second set of shots we see a little more on the left-hand side.  Nothing terribly significant, though.
Next we come to Animal Crackers, the second Broadway adaptation. It's slightly less stagey, but just barely.  You definitely get the feeling like you're seeing a lot of this material just as it was performed on stage, which isn't a criticism at all.  This time Groucho and Zeppo are a famous African explorer and his assistant.  A famous painting is being revealed at his gala return party, thrown by Margaret Dumont, but many complications arise.  Two of Dumont's jealous neighbors decide to replace the painting with a shoddy imitation as a prank.  And Dumont's daughter, played by Lillian Roth, also wants to replace the painting, so that her painter boyfriend can have the limelight.  And of course, two small-time crooks show up to get in the middle of everything.  It falls to Captain Spaulding to solve the case, Harpo goes on a shooting spree(!), and Groucho sings the most famous song of his career.  Things really start to get downright surreal here, and that's another reason why I love the Marx Bros.
A scene on the 2016 blu not shown on any previous home video version.
Now Animal Crackers is the truly restored film in this lot, with the lost footage restored.  I've searched and searched online and couldn't find exactly what was restored, with most reviews cited the same "I think I'll try and make her" example.  So I've broken down all of the differences in this fresh restoration.  There are a few examples (for instance, at 6:50 when Capt. Spaulding is first carried into the house), where only a frame or two has been restored to the ends of a scene.  Everything else, I'm listing below:

9:20 "I think I'll try and make her" line restore to the "Hurray for Captain Spalding" song.

36:20 Harpo biting the woman's top off has been restored[pictured above].

47:59 Restored dialogue between Dumont and Groucho, "oh, Captain, how thrilling!  And then what happened?"  "Oh, it was nothing at all.  I'd rather not discuss it." "Oh, but I can't wait to hear the finish; I must hear it!"  "Well, there I was.  There I was in the top of the tree with this rhinoceros pointing his gun straight at me." "A rhinoceros?"  "Yes."  "Oh Captain, what did you do?" "What could I do?  I had to marry his daughter." "What kind of story do you call that?"  "All right, you tell one."

1:09:10 The missing frames that make Chico's talk with the girl jump are fixed.

1:12:17 Restored lines to Groucho's letter for Zeppo: "Dear Elsie.  No, never mind Elsie." "Do you want me to scratch Elsie?" "Well, if you enjoy that sort of thing, it's quite all right with me. However, I'm not interested in your private affairs, Jamison. Begin this way. Let's start all over again."

1:14:17 More restored lines to the letter: "'Dear Elsie, scratch'." "That won't do, Jamison. That won't go through the mail, the way you got it. The way you've got the letter, you've got McCormick scratching Elsie. Now, you better turn that around and have Elsie scratch McCormick. And you better turn McCormick around, too, Jamison. And see what you can do for me."

1:18:48 Restored footage in the scene of Harpo being interrogated by the girl: "that still isn't what I want!" Harpo hits her with his papers and she points her finger, "you know what I want." Harpo looks bashful, and when she turns around, he smacks her behind with his paper.
Besides having all that lost footage restored, which is terrific, Animal Crackers is also by far the best restoration in terms of picture quality.  The framing is improved to give us additional picture on both sides, and more on the bottom as opposed to the top, which looks considerably better, as there's a lot of floating head space and things are tightly cropped along the bottom of the old DVD (for example, see Harpo's feet in the first set of shots).  Animal Crackers has always been the one interlaced transfer in all the previous Silver Screen Corrections.  The other four films didn't have this problem, but for whatever reason, it hadn't been fixed for this film until now.  Plus it's sharper and so much clearer, and has the stronger contrast that all the blus here have, making this a truly different viewing experience.

I'll also point out here that the subtitles have been considerably improved, too.  Where the DVD subs always short-handed some moments, dropping words and phrases (as in the "highly" and "magnificent" in the second set of shots), the blu is more complete.  The timing is also better, matching the delivery on-screen much more closely.  Somebody really cared in making these improvements.
Next we come to Monkey Business, the first film not taken from a Broadway show (though much of their bits through all the rest of these films borrow from their old stage acts).  The result is a faster pace, even wilder, less predictable story.  This time the four brothers are all stowaways on an ocean liner.  Zeppo meets the girl, who happens to be the daughter of a billionaire, who hires Chico and Harpo as bodyguards to protect him from some gangsters.  Meanwhile, the gangster hires Groucho and Zeppo to take out the billionaire.  But surprisingly little time is devoted to this fun story of cross purposes, which devotes more timer to Groucho romancing Thelma Todd, the gangster's moll, Harpo getting caught up in a children's puppet show, Chico paying one of his most memorable piano solos and everyone trying to pass themselves off as Maurice Chevalier.
Again, a stronger, cleaner image, you really notice it in motion.  This time we actually lose a smidgen on the sides, and trade some bottom for some top.  Animal Crackers is the only one where it matters much, though.  On all these others, it's a matter of slivers, and the blu-rays are basically just your standard jump of roughly the same transfer (though the framing tells us it's not exactly the same one) from SD to HD.
Film four is Horse Feathers, where Groucho is appointed head of his son's college.  Oh yeah, his son is Zeppo.  They get into a love triangle with the college widow, Thelma Todd again, and hire Harpo and Chico to help them rig the big game against the rival college.  Moving away from the Broadway musicals, the films get a little shorter and tighter.  The focus is more on the Marx Brothers than some arbitrary pair of ingénues, though Zeppo sometimes fills that role for a bit now, too.  The songs are almost all by the brothers and Horse Feathers features their greatest song of their career, "Everyone Says I Love You."  Woody Allen even named one of his films after it.
Look how muddy and bland the DVD looks compared to the blu-ray.  In the best shots, these new transfers really do make you feel closer to the cast in the 1930s than ever before.  Again, the framing's shifted a bit, but not so we get any additional picture, just so much as slivers on alternate sides.  There are some dropped frames, including little chunks worth that really make the scene jump and drop bits of dialogue.  It's all in the one scene with all the brothers running through Thelma's apartment, and they've always been missing on all the previous releases and... they unfortunately still are.  After Animal Crackers, I had my hopes up.  But what can you do if better elements don't exist?  Oh well, this is still the best the film has ever looked.
The last film is my favorite, not just of these five but all the Marx Brothers' films, Duck Soup.  It's the shortest and most insane.  Aside from a few running gags, it's impossible to guess what's going to happen from one scene to the next.  The country of Freedonia is bankrupt, again, and Marget Dumont refuses to lend them anymore of her fortune unless they make Groucho their new leader.  He of course appoints his brothers to key cabinet positions, and winds up causing and fighting a war.  Chico becomes a spy, Harpo terrorizes a lemonade stand, and Zeppo is almost cut entirely out of the picture.  The film is short, to the point where it doesn't even have time for Chico and Harpo's regular musical solos.  Tons of extras, big sets, bursting bombs and non-stop gags.  At one point Groucho even shoots his own men - why not? - and Chico and Harpo take on his trademark persona in a scene they'd later recreate on I Love Lucy.
2004 Silver Screen DVD on top; 2016 Silver Screen blu-ray bottom.
This might be the mildest improvement of the five.  Besides Animal Crackers, it's all sort of splitting hairs, but there's still a clear benefit in the jump from SD to HD on, say, Monkey Business.  Here, these shots are virtually indistinguishable.  If I mislabeled the screenshots, I'd have a hard time telling the DVD and blu-ray's apart.  The DVD's a bit paler, and I'm not saying there's no difference; but if this was all the set had to offer, I wouldn't have upgraded.

Audio-wise, all the DVDs had Dolby 2.0 mono tracks, and the blus naturally bump them up to DTS-HD 2.0 mono.  All the sound has imperfections baked right into how they were originally record, so it's never amazing; but it's as good as you'd expect.  The blu-rays drop the Spanish dub, which was always amusing to check in on for a quick second but hardly an important loss. The DVDs also had the English HOH, plus French and Spanish subtitles, while the blu-rays have just the English and Spanish.
The bonus disc in the old Silver Screens DVD set was fairly paltry.  It had three Today Show interviews: one with Groucho, one with Harpo and one with Harpo's son, Bill Marx.  They're amusing and certainly worth watching for any fan.  But they total about five minutes each, for a grand total of just over fifteen; and there's no reason they needed a sixth disc for them, rather then just sticking them on with the movies, except to be able to say that their set now includes a "Bonus Disc."  The DVDs also included trailers for four of the movies (excluding The Cocoanuts), and a 38 page booklet with pictures and biographical details about the brothers.
The blu-ray set really steps the game up.  This time, each film has an audio commentary by a different film historian.  Duck Soup has two, including Leonard Maltin, and the critic on Monkey Business is joined by Harpo's son. They're all quite good, though the problem with having multiple people is they don't know what was already said on the other tracks and tend to each repeat many of the same anecdotes as if they were the first time we'd heard it.  After that, we get the same Today Show interviews, and an all new documentary called Hollywood's Kings of Chaos (in 1.78:1, HD), which is pretty good, but it does get quite redundant with the commentaries, featuring many of the same critics and Bill Marx, although they also add Dick Cavett, Groucho's grandson, and a couple TV writers.  They're also not too subtle about covering the first five films in depth and then jumping right to their post Hollywood careers.  Strangely, and disappointingly, they got rid of the trailers.  Minor, but a bit of a bummer all the same.  Oh, but they do include a nice booklet with excerpts from one of the critic's book on the brothers, which is an improvement on the old booklet.
So any blu-ray lover into the Marx Brothers will have to get this set; and they'll be pleased when they do.  But even more casual viewers who might ordinarily say, "eh, I'm happy with the DVDs" should consider replacing them for the restored Animal Crackers, plus the new special features.  Despite the repetition at times, the commentaries are great.  And really, getting Animal Crackers uncut for the first time ever is just one of those moments we still buy movies for in the first place.

Perfect for Halloween: The Killing of Satan!

If you're anything like me, you know you need this movie in your life just from the cover.  Now, does the movie actually live up to that picture?  Well actually, surprisingly, pretty much, yes.  Does a guy in jeans contend with a giant snake, a lady who shape-shifts into a killer dog, a zombie and a red devil?  You bet!  This is The Killing of Satan, a 1984 Filipino horror adventure that delivers all of that and plenty more.  Not since Coffin Joe went directly to Hell in This Night I'll Possess Your Corpse has Old Nick come to such vivid on-screen life.  It's a perfect creature feature for Halloween night.
So how to begin explaining this film?  Well, it's a bit like Harry Potter in that our hero, Lando (you'll remember his name by the end of this movie, that's a promise), comes from the average, everyday world.  But he's brought into a different world early on where everybody around him and just about every character we meet from then on is some kind of wizard.  He has to quickly learn to use the magical powers he never knew he had as he fights the bad guys.  See, Lando's uncle is one of the top wizards in his little village, but the evil Prince of Magic and his thugs mortally wound him.  So he has to use the last of his powers to summon Lando from the city to come to his peoples' rescue.  In classic hero's journey-form, Lando refuses the call, but then some other thugs shoot him and his son, and the uncle uses the last of his magical life force to save him, so then he's really obligated to go.
full frontal nudity in all its interlaced glory
So Lando goes to the village and just as he's finding out that his uncle is dead and that he has hidden magical powers, the prince attacks again!  I've just seen the new Dr. Strange with Benedict Cumberbatch, and this is kind of like the low budget Filipino version of that.  Magic spells back and forth, ray beams, gushing winds, and an awesome spinning spell you just have to see for yourself.  This time the prince capture's most of the villages women, who he keeps trapped naked in a cage with magical bars and forces them to do his bidding with some magical neckbands.  Lando and his buddy race off to save them, but before they can reach the prince and his men, they has to face a whole collection of weirdos in their path, including a naked snake man, evil seductresses and a mysterious mute child who can lead them on their way.  I won't spoil the second half, but all that stuff on the poster happens and Lando not only confronts the prince, but works his way up the chain to fight one on one with Satan himself.
If you want overly ambitious 80s special effects, this is your Christmas morning.  Yeah, it's all cheap, horribly dubbed and clearly poorly acted even underneath that dubbing.  But that's just part of the charm.  One of the things that really keeps this film entertaining is that there's always something new.  A cavalcade of monsters and constantly varying special effects.  Sure, sometimes they shoot rotoscoped beams at each other, but other times it's a super-imposed pinwheel or an on-set wind machine blowing people over.  If they'd managed to squeeze in a little stop-motion, this would be a full-blown Harryhausen adventure, always ready to throw you a curve ball.  The film seems somewhat old school and chaste until you hit the scenes of extreme gore and full frontal nudity.  I mean, don't get me wrong, the film's terrible in all the traditional senses - it's the kind of movie my mother can't understand why I would ever want to watch it.  But it's also a kind of wonderful that very few movies can ever begin to live up to.  It could have made a perfect episode of Mystery Science Theater 3000 (and after the kickstarter, who knows, it still might), but most of those movies, taken without their riffing, are deathly dull.  This one's a blast all on its own.
Unfortunately, The Killing of Satan is pretty much M.I.A. on the home video front.  It's one of those titles desperately in need of a cult label's attention.  But it's not completely unavailable.  There is a grey market DVD from Substance, the same label that brought us that crappy Monster Dog DVD.  And this DVD lives down to those standards of crappiness.  Full screen?  Of course.  Soft and smeary?  Just like melting ice cream.  Sourced from a video tape?  Looks that way.  Seriously interlaced?  Oh yeah!  Buzzing sound?  Check.  Bizarre vertical line of video noise running up the right-hand side of the picture through the entire movie?  Why yes, now that you mention it.
And what about extras?  The director, Efren C. Piñon, has made almost fifty cult and exploitation films, and its writer is an award winning filmmaker who's still in the business to this very day!  The cast and crew is full of successful Filipino actors and effects artists with tons of film and television credits.  Do we get to hear from any of them?  Ha ha ha!  This is a Substance release, there isn't even a trailer.  The only thing we get is a "Gallery" which just consists of still shots taken from the exact same video transfer the main film plays in.  Although, I have to admit, their menu screen is pretty cool.
The devil takes many forms, or at least two, in The Killing of Satan!
Yes, this film is badly in need of an HD restoration, and the good news is: it's possible!  Apparently Drafthouse has been known to screen this natural crowd pleaser on 35mm.  So if just a couple of the right people make the right phone calls, we could conceivably have an amazing looking 2k scan of this film in HD widescreen!  Seriously, this and Spookies, those guys need to get off their butts and put this out on their own label or let somebody like Arrow get hold of it.  But in the meantime, at least there's the Substance.

Welcome To Manhattan Baby

Welcome to Lucio Fulci's most unfairly maligned horror film.  1982's Manhattan Baby seems to get even more flack than his real clunkers like Voices From Beyond or Door Into Silence; fans just seem to love putting this one down.  I mean, sure you can say that Manhattan Baby is silly, poorly dubbed, un-scary and illogical... you know, like all of Fulci's greatest works.  But it's got some cool production values, another nightmarish "anything goes" plot, various gruesome kills, and one of his best soundtracks.  No, it's not on the level of The Beyond or City Of the Living Dead, but I'd put it about even with The Black Cat.  I mean, the pros and cons are very different for this and Black Cat, but in the final tally they come up about the same for me.  And now, maybe this fancy, new special edition from Blue Underground will scare up some more favorable reappraisals from you guys, too.
So what's this one about?  Well, a happy American family go on vacation to Egypt, where their daughter is given a mysterious amulet.  They go back home (to Manhattan, hence the title), and naturally it turns out that the amulet brought a bunch of evil supernatural problems with it.  The father goes blind, the son gets pulled through a dimensional gateway into the ghost world a la Poltergeist, people get possessed, animals attack. peoples' eyes bleed.  It's almost everything you want from a Fulci film.  Predictably, there's an older gentleman who can tell the family about the evil they've inflicted with and try to tell them save themselves from this ancient Egyptian curse.
I've already weighed most of the pros and cons.  It's kind of like an Egyptian-themed Exorcist with some extra Fulci-madness layered on top.  But it does have slower scenes of exposition that slow it down, and again, it never reaches the heights of The Beyond, and falls a little short of the consistent atmosphere of House By the Cemetery.  But Fulci lovers should be delighted by the return of Bob!  I mean, it's not actually the same character, but it's the same kid dubbed by the same woman.  The fact that Fulci seems to have actually shot at least some exterior scenes with the cast in both Egypt and Manhattan certainly gives this film some 'scope, not to mention his usual, excellent widescreen cinematography.  It is lacking one or two great gore highlights to really place it in the history books alongside his most famous work, and the father does look ridiculous wearing his glasses over his big eye bandages, but this is still a solid entry in his oeuvre as far as I'm concerned.
Manhattan Baby debuted on DVD in 2001 with a nice, anamorphic widescreen transfer from Anchor Bay.  I've still got that disc, so we'll be looking at it today.  They repackaged it as an appropriate double-feature with The New York Ripper in 2002.  Then, in 2007, Blue Underground acquired the rights and reissued the same disc.  But now, finally in 2016, we have an actual new edition, as Blue Underground takes the film into the HD age with their new "3-Disc Limited Edition."  I put that in quotes because I'm literally quoting the case, and because I think it's a stretch to call this a 3-disc edition, although technically, yes it is.  Nightbreed, Army of Darkness?  Those are real 3-disc special editions, where each disc includes important, unique video content: extras, different versions of the film.  This set is a combo-pack, so disc 2 is exactly the same as disc 1, except that it's a DVD copy of the blu-ray.  And the 3rd disc is a CD.  So advertising like it's on par with a proper 3-disc edition, well; we all know what Judge Judy says about peeing on her leg, right?  But don't get me wrong, it's still a pretty awesome single-disc blu-ray special edition, as we're about to see!
2001 Anchor Bay DVD 1st, 2016 BU DVD 2nd, 2016 BU blu-ray 3rd.
2001 Anchor Bay DVD left, 2016 BU blu-ray right.
Blue Underground's new transfer comes from a fresh 2k scan taken of the original camera negatives.  The HD is much sharper and clearer than the old DVD with kosher grain and more natural colors.  The framing has been corrected slightly from 2.35:1 to 2.39:1, and in addition to that, we're also zoomed out a little farther so we get more picture info on all four sides.  Admittedly, that does open the door for some dirt and debris along the very top that we'd never seen before, but overall I'd definitely call it an improvement.  We're talking more than the usual sliver here; look at the mirror on the left side of Tommy's room.  But don't try to look for it on the AB disc; it's not there.  The old DVD was actually a pretty solid transfer for it's time, so it's not a whole world of new detail, but as you can see in the close-up, it is a lot less grainy and soft.  And the new DVD version?  It kind of bridges the gap between the two, giving us the new scan, but still has a soft look to it compared to the blu.

Audio-wise, The old DVDs gave us the original mono in Dolby 2.0, with no subs.  Blue Underground gives us the choice between a modern 5.1 mix and the original mono, both in DTS-HD.  The Italian track might've been a nice addition, especially since they're already including subtitles in English, Spanish and French; but as long as we have the mono, I'm happy enough.
For extras, we've only had a brief but interesting interview with the writer, Dardano Sacchetti, plus the trailer.  Curiously, it also had hidden notes by Michael Felsher on the reverse of the cover [pictured right], even though it came in a solid black case so most owners probably never even found them.  Anyway, thankfully, Blue Underground has preserved the interview and trailer, so you can go ahead and chuck your old DVDs.  And they've also given us a bunch more.  Finally, Manhattan Baby has a special edition.

Now, the music seems to be the one aspect of Manhattan Baby that everybody can agree on, so we get a lot about that.  They talk to Fabio Frizzi for just about an hour, not only about this film but his entire career and collaboration with Fulci.  Then we get another featurette of him performing a Manhattan Baby suite.  Next, moving out of the music, we get on-camera interviews with Cosimo Cinieri, who played the mysterious Mercato, and special effects artist Maurizo Trani, plus a poster and stills gallery.  And that CD?  It's the official film soundtrack.  Like I said, the music is the main thing with this film.  Blue Underground also includes a nice 20-page booklet with extensive notes by Troy Howarth, and we get cool reversible art showing us the film's alternate title, Eye Of the Evil Dead.
If you're a Fulci fan, I recommend you give this film another shot.  And this terrific new Blue Underground release is the ideal way to do it.  If they come out with a non-limited single disc edition, though, I'd say that would be every bit as good, unless you're really into these soundtrack CDs.  Personally, I never listen to 'em, and redundant DVDs?  No thanks.  But the single blu-ray is pretty kick-ass.

Titled Woody Allen Project 2016: Café Society (DVD/ Blu-ray Comparison)

Once again, it's that time of year... the new Woody Allen is here!  It's a great, reliable traditional.  Each summer we get a new Woody Allen film in theaters, and each Fall/ early Winter, we get it on DVD and blu-ray.  Even this year, when he paused production to write and direct a (quite good!) mini-series for Amazon "television," he still delivered another top quality film right on time.  And just to bring home how impressively consistent this is, Allen hasn't missed his one-film-a-year schedule since 1976!  And you bet, "Untitled Woody Allen Project 2017" is already listed on the imdb as filming, starring Kate Winslet and Justin Timberlake.  But let's not get ahead of ourselves.  What's our movie for 2016?  Café Society!
So let's start by answering what we all want to know about a new Woody Allen picture?  Is he starring in it?  No, though he does narrate.  Instead we have Jesse Eisenberg (To Rome With Love) essentially in the Woody role.  He starts definitely giving a Woody-like performance, though the character evolves into something I don't think Allen could really play as the film progresses.  In our story, Eisenberg leaves Manhattan for California with dreams of hitting it big in late 1930s Hollywood.  That's not as unrealistic a goal as it might seem, because his uncle, Steve Carell (in a role originally cast with Bruce Willis, who got replaced), is a big shot film agent.  So he gets a job doing small jobs for his uncle and swiftly falls in love with his secretary, Kristen Stewart, not knowing that she's having a secret affair with Carell.  When she chooses Carell over him, he moves back to New York to go into the nightclub business with his gangster brother and Blake Lively.  But of course you know their paths will cross again...
This is a beautiful looking film, shot by the Academy Award winning DP of Reds and Apocalypse Now, Vittorio Storaro, and full of long, sharp tracking shots.  There's a great cast, also including Parker Posey and a cameo by Twin Peaks' Sheryl Lee.  Even Stewart, though not exactly a surprising scene stealer, was more than capable and certainly superior to her time in those Twilight movies.  The old Hollywood stuff lends itself to some nice moments and costumes, but this movie doesn't get caught up in tribute like Midnight In Paris; it's just focused on the effective, if familiar, story.  You've seen all these themes in Allen's work before; but it's still an excellent execution.
I was a little worried that Amazon acquiring Allen's latest film for distribution meant it would be trapped in streaming-only limbo or something, or just an MOD thing like they did with Wiener-Dog.  But no, they promptly issued DVD and blu-ray releases through Lions Gate.  In fact, the blu is a combo-pack, so I can give us an SD/ HD comparison, too.
2016 Lions Gate DVD on top; 2016 Lions Gate blu-ray on bottom.
2016 Lions Gate DVD right; 2016 Lions Gate blu-ray left.
Let Allen start shooting digitally, and he gives us a film in 2.00:1.  Unusual, but the compositions look great, so no complaints.  And the image quality looks terrific in HD, with lots of excellent detail and color.  It's sharp and looks filmic except for the lack of grain.  In SD, though, you get a lot of compression smudginess and you lose a lot of small detail.  If you're a viewer who only sometimes springs for blu-ray and other times still picks up DVDs to save a few bucks, you'll find it's worth the extra cost on this one.  Audio is a nice 5.1 mix in DTS-HD on the blu, and we're given English, English HOH and Spanish subtitle options.
It tells you how starved we've become for extras on Woody Allen releases that I'm actually excited for the tiny little promo featurette they've started including on Allen's last couple releases.  This one is the shortest yet, clocking in at two minutes and thirteen seconds.  At least it's not padded with film clips!  It's just very brief interview clips with Posey, Stewart and Lively on the red carpet before the film's premiere.  There's also a stills gallery of promotional and behind-the-scenes photos.  No trailer.  It does come in a nice slip cover, though.
Lions Gate has given us an excellent release of a very good film.  Sure it's light on extras, but it's Woody Allen; that's par for the course.  So besides that, there's not much more you could ask for than what we've got.  Now, hopefully they'll give us a physical release of Crisis In Six Scenes.  If not, I'll see you all here next year for Untitled Woody Allen Project 2017.

What To Get the Errol Morris Fan Who Has Everything: First Person

Errol Morris's First Person is probably my all-time favorite television series, so naturally I'm going to cover the DVD set from MGM.  But if you're at all interested in documentary films, you're probably at least familiar with it already.  So I also want to dig a little deeper, because there's also a much more obscure, slightly older First Person DVD self-released by Morris's own company, Globe Department Store, that has an extra treat for the really serious fan.
First Person is an interview-focused documentary series that plays just like Errol Morris's later films.  In fact, the only reason why The Unknown Known or Fog of War couldn't have fit right into the series as additional episodes is that they have longer run times.  Sure, in his earlier films he tended to go out on locations and talk to a ton of people.  But since he created the Interrotron, he's definitely moved into a style of singular, concentrated and, well, first person interviews.  And the show also incorporates his usual editing style of cutting between multiple angles of the interviewee, often looking directly into camera, with silent clips of vintage film footage and occasional cut-aways played to music.
Errol's certainly mastered his presentation, but what makes these episodes so fascinating and endlessly rewatchable are the interviews themselves.  Some are a little famous, but more often than not he finds the most compelling people you've never heard of.  But it doesn't matter; by this time I've learned if Morris wants to talk to them, you're going to want to hear what makes them tick.  A psychologist who used to write letters to the unabomber, a Who Wants To Be a Millionaire contestant who forged his personal records so he could go back to high school a second time, a cryogenic scientist (a known passion; he's been trying to make a movie on the subject for many years) who froze his mother's head.  Things definitely tend to veer into the odd side, but it's never a freak show; it's just interesting people who are going through life a little bit differently than the rest of us.
So First Person ran from 2000-2002 on Bravo/ IFC, and for several years, we were calling out for a DVD release with no response insight.  And remember this was in the heyday of the DVD era, not like today, where many shows don't get physical releases.  Finally, in 2004, Morris took matters into his own hands and released a single episode (One In a Milliontrillion) through his own company, Globe Department Store.  This was to show labels how successful it could be, and apparently it was enough, because in the following year, MGM released the full series in a 3-disc set.
Ugh.  These came out in 2004 and 2005, but they look like they're from 1998 and 1999.  Non-anamorphic widescreen, interlaced, soft and full of artifacts.  The aspect ratio shifts between seasons, from 1.63:1 to 1.77:1, and it doesn't get any more anamorphic in the second season.  The Globe and MGM discs look basically the same and share all the same issues, except the blacks are a little light on the Globe disc, one minor thing MGM fixed, at least.  Both have strong stereo tracks and no subtitle options.
Bonus scene only on the Globe Department Store DVD
So why should anyone care about the Globe Department disc if it's just one episode that's already in the set, where it actually looks slightly better?  Just to have a collector's item?  No, because the MGM set is completely barebones.  Like, not even chapter breaks.  And, each disc in the set starts with that awful "YOU WOULDN'T STEAL A CAR, WOULD YOU?" commercial.  Really, the discs are so poor, it's like MGM made them out of spite.  But the Globe disc does have extras, at least a little.  And it's quality stuff; not like some generic promo feature.  There's 11 minutes of additional footage from the episode.  And it's really interesting, just as good as anything that's in the final cut.  Clearly this stuff was cut for time because of television's rigid time slots, not because of content.  If you loved the episode, you definitely want to see this footage.  Oh and yes, the Globe disc has chapter breaks and no "CAR" commercial.  Oh, and both releases do include inserts, if those even blips on anyone's radar.
First Person is the most criminally underrated show ever.  The MGM discs suck, an especially poor show from a major studio, but they're still essential by virtue of being the best we've got of an amazing series.  And if you're a fan, there is an amazon listing for that Globe Department DVD, and it's surprisingly still reasonably priced all these years later.  I think just because nobody really even knows about them.  Oh, and just for the record, there is one episode of the series (Mr. Personality) included on MGM's DVD of The Thin Blue Line as like a bonus feature, but that episode's in the set and is just as non-anamorphic and crappy looking there.  Maybe we could talk Criterion into taking these on?  Restoring these in HD would be a huge difference, we know Morris could provide some great interviews for extras, and if every episode has extra footage like One In a Milliontrillion, oh man; it could be one of their top releases!