It's time for another edition of Controversial Blus! Just released today is the brand new Restored Edition of
An American Werewolf In London blu-ray from Paramount. According to the sticker on the slip, it's "NEWLY RESTORED FOR IMPROVED HD PICTURE," so we're not just talking about a reissue of the previous release with different art masquerading as a new version to trap enthusiastic double-dippers
like some other releases I can think of. This is actually an all new transfer. But is it actually better? The new blu seems to be receiving more than its fair share criticisms... I think it's time I did a direct comparison. And as you can see from the picture above, I'll be looking at some of the older DVDs at the same time.
Update 9/28/16 - 10/22/19: And I'll also be looking at the even more recently restored and improved HD release from Arrow, scheduled to be released at the end of this month. Spoiler alert: the controversy is now behind us.
Updated 4/12/21: I'm getting a little tired of updating this movie, but if we're being honest with ourselves, we all knew a proper UHD couldn't be too far behind those 4k BDs, right? And this Turbine set should be the final chapter for a long time to comee now. Right?
An American Werewolf In London is a pretty great movie, with a modern appeal yet a very traditional, throwback werewolf plot at its core. Two friends go hiking across England and get attacked by a werewolf after being warned by the creepy locals to not go out on a full moon. The survivor, of course, wakes up back in the city hospital with a nasty, lycanthropic curse. While he falls in love with his nurse and tries to get on with his life, his primal nature breaks free as he transforms, spectacularly, into a werewolf and begins terrorizing London. His doctor suspects and begins to investigate, and even his dead best friend returns(!) to warn him, but true love may be the only thing that can save our tragic protagonist.
John Landis has created one of the most successful blends of horror and comedy, where neither aspect spoils the other. And it holds up really well, thanks largely to the well-crafted characters, not to mention the famous, cutting edge effects, which still look better than anything coming out today. It's also a clever story with great use of music and some terrific locations. Having a healthy budget clearly helped in all the right places, from big set pieces to music licensing.
American Werewolf is one of those rare horror movies that manages to appeal to mainstream audiences without losing the core genre fans. They've tried to recapture the magic with some success - Landis with a vampire tale called
Innocent Blood and the studio with a sequel:
An American Werewolf In Paris, which wasn't terrible - but
An American Werewolf In London still stands head and furry shoulders above.
Paramount has released
An American Werewolf In London a number of times. I don't it would be too cynical to say that they see this film as a cash cow that can always take a little more milking. Even limiting it to just the United States, Paramount has issued it on disc an awful lot of times. actually, Artisan put it out on DVD first in 1997, with a barebones fullscreen disc. So Universal's widescreen Collector's Edition was a welcome upgrade in 2001. There was also a bundle release in 2004 with the 2001 disc and the remake of
Cat People. Then the two-disc Full Moon edition added a couple more features, and also came out with a blu-ray edition, both in 2009, so that was a good upgrade. Then they re-released the 2-disc set as a single disc release, shaving off some extras for a more budget release in 2012. Okay. Then in 2014, the blu-ray was released with a gold "Academy Award" winner cover, but it was the same disc as the original blu-ray. That same year, they also released it in a limited edition steelbook. In 2016, Universal released their Restored Edition before finally handing the property over to someone who knew what to do with it for Arrow's 2019 Limited Edition 4k remaster. It was pretty much the definitive BD edition, but now BDs aren't the definitive discs anymore. So at the end of 2020, Turbine released it on UHD as an "Ultimate Edition" 4-disc set (if you count the soundtrack CD). And now in 2021, they've just reissued it as a Limited Special Edition 3-disc set, with all the same video content, but minus the swag.
 |
1) 2001 DVD, 2) 2009 DVD, 3) 2009 BD, 4) 2016 BD;
5) 2019 BD; 6) 2021 BD; 7) 2021 UHD. |
So, all seven releases are 1.85:1, but you'll notice the old 2001 DVD is missing a little around all four sides, particularly the left. Actually, measuring it, that first DVD is more like 1.82:1. Even just comparing the two DVDs, you can see the later one is sharper with more naturalistic colors, too, if maybe a tiny bit on the yellow side. And then the old blu-ray is that same 2009 DVD transfer - note the white hole in the picture around the wolfman's wrist; it looks like he's wearing a fancy diamond bracelet - but a little cleaner because it's in HD. The grain is really strong there, and it was definitely the best looking version up 'till then. But then we come to the Restored Edition, and... where'd the grain go?
 |
| l to r: 2009 BD; 2016 BD; 2019 BD; 2021 UHD. |
Apparently, the film was given a brand new, 6k(!) scan for this
restoration, and my best guess is they figured if they scanned it that
close, they could apply some DNR (digital noise reduction) and not lose
all the usual detail that tends to go with heavy DNR application.
That's why seeing "DNR" is a bad sign in a blu-ray review. It means the
picture is going to be unnaturally smooth and waxy, with detail
erased. Peoples' hair will look like clear plastic helmets, etc. So
bye-bye
American Werewolf grain, and it does look a little bit
softer, but... they seem to have been right in that the actual detail
has pretty much remained. I've seen some people say there's even more
detail than the old blu, but I wouldn't go that far. Universal's 2016
BD is the most successful attempt I think I've ever seen to remove grain
without smoothing away much of the image. Still, it was a little weird
to look knowing film grain should be there, and now that we can see the
results of Arrow's even more recent 4k scan (finished in 2k), we see
Universal's job wasn't perfect. I've read allegations that the grain on
the 2009 edition is "fake," or artificially enhanced (it was even
brought up in the comments, below), and I was reluctant to buy into that
notion, but Arrow's new scan seems to bear it out. Now we finally see
the natural levels of grain you'd expect to see in a 35mm film, making
the 2009's look chunky and unnatural. The 2019 image seems even more
nuanced, and a tiny bit sharper, than even the 2016 blu, and it still
has the clean-up (i.e. no diamond bracelet!). How could a 4k scan look
better than a 6k scan? When you don't futz with it afterwards!
 |
| l to r: 2019 BD; 2021 UHD. |
Now, just comparing BDs, I actually still prefer Arrow's, with an encode that thoroughly captures every speck of grain. But of course, we didn't buy Turbine's set for the 1080 blu, we bought it for the UHD. And there's just no competing with that boost in resolution. Let's zoom in even further, and you can see where the eyeball, for example, breaks down into blocky pixels on the blu while it's still smooth and lifelike on the UHD. That's not a knock on Arrow; it's just a fact of life when we're dealing with a superior format. Grain looks a little gentler on the Turbine disc, but again, when you really zoom in, there's no question it's more authentically represented and less pixelated. And of course now you've got the new HDR color timing, which is what you're really going to notice on your television, as opposed to an academic screenshot comparison, and it really does give the image a more alive, sometimes creepier, feel without ever becoming over saturated or tacky. It's actually more subtle and nuanced.
For audio, both Universal blus pretty give us the same English DTS-HD
5.1 mix, plus both have a Spanish DTS dub in 5.1, and French, German and
Italian DTS dubs in mono. Both blus also have 16(!) subtitle options,
which I won't bother to list out, but that's pretty much every language
including both English and English SDH. A number of fans were hoping
for the original English mono track, but we didn't get that. Landis
created the updated 5.1 mix himself, so I imagine there was little
interest in putting the old track back on the film. Sorry, purists.
The older DVDs also only have the English in 5.1 (plus, English, Spanish
and French subs), though
I've read
that the mix on the old Artisan DVD at least sounds closer to the
original audio, with a higher pitch. But you had to go all the way back
to the old laserdiscs (there's a fullscreen one from Image and a
widescreen one from Live) for the original mono audio.
I say "had," because Arrow have once again swooped in to save the day,
because they've also restored and remastered the original mono from the
original mag reels for their new disc! So the pitch is finally
correct. That and the 5.1 mix are both included on the Arrow in DTS-HD, along
with optional English subs. and as for the Turbine? Yes, they're pitch corrected, too. Whew! They've also got both the 2.0 and 5.1 mixes in DTS-HD, plus the German dub in same, with optional English and German subtitles.
For extras, once Universal got it, things were looking good. The
original 2001 DVD had a light but not too informative audio commentary
by the two leads
David Naughton and
Griffin Dunne, a substantial on-camera interview with John Landis, another with
Rick Baker,
outtakes, a vintage 'making of' feature, and some archival footage of
Baker working on the famous werewolf transformation. Plus it had a
photo gallery, storyboards, text bios, a bonus trailer for
The Wolfman
(the remake) and a nice little insert with notes. The 2009 DVD and
every subsequent release carried all of that over (except the bios,
bonus trailer and junk), but also added a full length documentary on the
film called
Beware the Moon (that's the second disc of the
2-disc set that was dropped from the budget version in 2012), which is
great and very thorough. The blu also added Universal's usual junk like
BD-Live and D-Box support for the two people who use that. And no, the
new 2016 doesn't have anything new to add, and even ditches the BD-Live
and D-Box stuff. It does come in a nice, shiny slipcover, though.
But who does have something new to add? Arrow, of course! First of
all, yes, everything from all the past editions (except the D-Box and
junk) has been carried over. And what's new? First and foremost an
excellent full-length documentary on Universal's history with werewolf
films by Ballyhoo, who really hit it out of the park. This was clearly
made with
AAWIL in mind, because it starts out with Landis and
never loses site of how all of this history is eventually leading to his
film. But it's a great look at the whole story (and even a bit of a
postscript on the
Del Toro film), interviewing a surprisingly
vast collection of filmmakers and artists. Beyond that, there's a new
interview with Landis, which isn't too redundant because they ask him
about British cinema and bits he hasn't touched on too much in the
previous extras. Then there's a new audio commentary by the director of
Beware the Moon (who also wrote a book on
AAWIL), which
is rather good. He's an undeniable expert on the film and manages to
find new trivia info to share despite the wealth of content in all the
other extras. Plus, he does a pretty funny Landis impression. But he
does also slip into repeating a bunch of anecdotes we've heard elsewhere
on the disc, often more than once.
Still want more? Whew, okay! There's a brief but quite neat look at
surviving props from the film, including one of Baker's legendary
"change-o heads." There's a video essay on the Jewish aspects of this
film, which are mostly quite interesting and well observed, though he
does spend a chunk of time unwittingly repeating some
Wolfman history that was already spelled out in the Ballyhoo doc, and he exaggerates a bit. Then there's an interview with
Corin Hardy, director of
The Nun,
which starts out kind of bland and uninteresting as he just shares his
appreciation of the film. But then he gets more interesting when he
starts applying his own experience in filmmaking to discuss the hurdles
he'd have trying to replicate what Landis achieved today. Oh, and I
even saw some forum guy post a strange video teaser for the film that he
was disappointed never made it onto any of the Universal blus. Well,
that's on here, too, along with the main theatrical trailer and a TV
spot.
The limited edition comes in a clear amary case with reversible artwork
housed inside an attractive, thick slipbox. It includes a two-sided
poster, six lobby cards, a full-color 60-page book with notes by
Travis Crawford and
Simon Ward and one of Arrow's standard insert cards (mine's for
Why Don't You Just Die!).
It's
a little confusing, because the title of several featurettes
were arbitrarily changed, but having gone through it all now, I'm happy
to report that every single special feature from the Arrow set has been
carried over to the Turbine. And even better, though you wouldn't have
thought it was possible, Turbine have included
even more new stuff: five features totaling up to roughly another hour
of content. A nice start is a brief look at Piccadilly Circus today,
with the film's first AD. The longest is a
Post Mortem retrospective with
Mick Garris
interviewing Landis, originally recorded, I believe, for his podcast
series. There's also a 2011 interview with David Naughton and a
round-table discussion with Garris, Landis,
John Carpenter and
David Cronenberg, which has popped up on a few discs before, including Criterion's
Videodrome and Turbine's edition of
The Thing.
But it's nice to finally get it on a Landis release - a welcome
addition to anyone who hasn't had a chance to see it yet. And finally,
there's a brief featurette with a fan who's collected a number of
impressive props and memorabilia from the film that was created for the
Arrow BD, but ultimately left off. Now we finally get to see it.
Turbine's
Limited Special Edition comes in a very stylish, embossed slipbox, and
the inner case also includes reversible artwork. Their initial 2020
Ultimate Edition also came with a soundtrack CD, double-sided poster, a
100-page book, art cards, stickers, and a Slaughtered Lamb "beer lid,"
whatever that is. All the extras are completely English-friendly (except the book? I just got the LSE, not the UE), and two of the trailers have also been boosted up to 4k resolution.
So the old debate of which blu is best is now handily closed: Arrow's
beats all those that came before it with a long lead. It brought the best
picture, finally looking natural after all of Universal's odd
experiments, the proper original audio (and the 5.1 remix, too, for
those who still want that), and the fullest, most well-rounded set of
extras. It's not even missing some little thing where a die-hard
collector might say, well, you might want to still hang onto your old
copy. And now Turbine have come along, and kicked it forward a generation, with a few more new extras to boot.
American Werewolf fans have nothing to complain about any more, it's one of the best served films on home video!
